Quote Originally Posted by hroşila View Post
But, by the time Redcloak recovered the real phylactery, the old jeweller had already crafted the fake one.

I don't think it's a problem, though - Xykon wouldn't be familiar with those new scratches either, since he barely got a look. And that's even assuming O-Chul managed to scratch it at all.
He wouldn't have managed to scratch it. Xykon straight-up says "It'll take more than a few whacks with a metal bar to scuff the finish, pally" when O-Chul tries. He also says that the phylactery has so many abjurations on it, he's forgotten what most of them do. Abjurations that render an object impervious to non-magical metal whacking are pretty basic.