Retiering the Classes (PF): Barbarian, Bloodrager, Fighter, Cavalier, Samurai

[upho]

Who's going to trade out all their bloodline powers for rage powers anyway? Anyone sensible with mix and match the best ones.

Of course not. The question was whether not trading any bloodline powers for rage powers could ever be considered the best choice. Which I don't think it can. IOW, Primalist is always going to be better than non-Primalist (maybe not considerably better, but still).

Also - jumping the gun a little - but which Paladin archetypes are you thinking Upho?

Mostly Empyreal Knight and Sacred Servant. Although admittedly, I haven't seen either in play for quite a while now and would have to check up on them again, and any more recent pally archetypes, before actually voting. So take my previous comments with a grain of salt.