Quote Originally Posted by Lacuna Caster View Post
No, that's still not right. Accusations of weak reasoning should be supportable by inspecting the argument, not the arguer.
In general that seems like a good idea, however:

In theory there is no difference between theory and practice, in practice there is.
There are a lot of ideas in the world, most of them are wrong, once I've identified that they are wrong, I don't care very much why or how they are wrong. I strongly suspect that if it had been Hitler whose logic I'd denied (as I certainly would), we wouldn't be having this discussion.

The thing about Marxists so far as I am concerned isn't that they believe one arbitrary wrong thing, it's that they believe a whole conjoined mess of wrong things, as do fascists, and a bunch of other groups, the particulars of which cannot be discussed here.

So, Amber's grabbed and disarmed him, apparently. I wonder what's next.