Quote Originally Posted by Psyren View Post
The D&D universe has a DM who would answer that question.
D&D games have DMs, the D&D universe doesn't.


Quote Originally Posted by Psyren View Post
That usually starts with agreeing on terms. You can't say "fire means something different in this universe therefore they can't burn each other." Either Magic A is Magic A and we can discuss, or not and not.
Literally no one has claimed that or anything tantamount to that. Objections were raised on two topics: are D&D artifacts and god created items equivalent, and whether or not the Marvel Astral Plane is the same as the D&D one.

I would be willing to accept the bit about artifacts and I could accept that Dr. Strange's spells are fundamentally different from D&D ones. But the Astral Planes being the same and AMF not blocking Stange's (non artifact) magic is where I disagree. Neither of those claims make any sense.