Darths and Droids V: Thread IV Was Eaten By Dogs

[Porthos]

Um, wow. That's... quite the rant there Peelee.

Not gonna address it much of it except to say that I adore that scene and whatever problems one might have with it border on nitpicks to me* and are pretty easily handwaved away from where I'm standing**.

* I realize they aren't nitpicks to you, just that they are to me, if you see what I mean.
** Ditto.

However, the big elephant in the room, I'll address in spoiler bars:

Spoiler: Still Massive Spoilers Here: Stay Away AWAY I SAY

Show

It's been commented on by TPTB that the Tantive IV was going to try for a diplomatic immunity gambit if/when they got caught. Was it a great plan? Well... No. But considering the circumstances of improv running around trying to keep a heads up on a massively chaotic, unplanned situation, it works well enough for me.

...

Plus the scene was absolutely KICK. ASS. so I can forgive potential Movie Logic here.

...

That and I still well up a tad at "Hope".

So. Yeah. Worked wonders for me. One of my favorite combined scenes in all of the movie franchise. Both in execution and setup. Sorry to hear it didn't work for you.