Quote Originally Posted by Arkhios View Post
Oh, I know that, but since this is 5e forum I kinda assumed people would refrain from talking about anything but.
I missed everything between 2 and 5. Sounds like maybe that was a good thing.

I can see a devotion paladin who takes fiendlock levels would have to resolve some very serious issues before going back to paladin, but I can't see making a character irredeemable by fiat. It's at least mostly up to the player to decide if the character is beyond redemption.

That said, looking back on it, the last time I DM'd a warlock trying to redeem himself I did a poor job of it, so I can see how it's easy to get wrong.