Quote Originally Posted by Max_Killjoy View Post
Based on the sum total of his posting, he is railroading, but also tries to define "railroading" as broadly as possible so that he can claim that railroading is good and that all competent GMs are railroading... and then conflate and confuse different contexts and different GM actions so as to fig-leaf his own actual railroading.
Maybe, all I see is that when confronted with a "would you let your players do this?" he responds with something along the lines of "they can do whatever they want."