Quote Originally Posted by Talamare View Post
Good and Evil are subjective

There is - Do the most Good
There is - Do the least Evil

You claim that Torture makes you Evil, which means you believe in Do the least Evil

If the Torture results* in saving of millions, then Do the most Good means that you're a Good person because you Tortured him.
You would be Evil if you refused, since it would be condemning millions for your personal selfishness


Disclaimer
(* I know Torture doesn't work, but we have to assume it does for a philosophical debate)
Actually what I was trying to say is that a good person wouldn't even think or attempt to torture someone, and would look for different, non-violent solutions to the problem, at least that's how I envision a good-aligned person.