Is there anything I can replace it with?
You say that it's good yet it has been consistently awful with virtually every creature of every type making their saves without issue.
I know Chill Touch is lacklustre but at least it does something.
Quicken and Twin.
Even though I only have 2 lv2 spell slots?
Also, in that case, what would you recommend?
Yeah, I was stupid enough to believe a guide to sorcerers on this site.
Joy.
What about choices for lv2+ spells?
I mean, I can swap around shield and mage armour, but as it stands my problem is not that I'm taking too much damage but that I'm just not inflicting any damage.
So the way to not suck with a sorcerer is to play a different class? Fantastic.