Expertise Feats

[ThePurple]

I gotta admit, I do love a gouge, with its minimum 4 damage per [W]. I particularly like a gouge of carnage so that rolling at least one '6' adds another slice of pain to the hurtwich.

That gets kind of weird.

Carnage reads "When you roll the maximum result on at least one of this weapon's damage dice"; "damage dice" is important here as is "maximum result". The *damage dice* for the gouge is 2d6, not 1d6. As such, I would only allow the carnage effect to trigger when you roll 2 6s on a pair (and, if you're running it in game, make sure the pairs are the same color to ensure that you don't mix pairs accidentally) because that's the maximum result of that specific damage die. If anything, a gouge would be *worse* for carnage because it's rolling multiple dice, which decreases the chances of getting a "maximum result" on any single "weapon damage die" (even if that die is technically multiple dice).