I'm sure this has been posted, or is just common knowledge, but there seems to be an arguement between our group whether or not you can use the same Shtick (such as Elan's Rapier) more than once in a single Battle Stack.

In other words, I use the rapier to fend off a kobold, and then use the same rapier shtick to fend off a ogre underneath him.

The argument has come up over the phrase "Select a new battle shtick" when describing proceeding past the first opponent.

Thanks for the help.