Quote Originally Posted by Dion View Post
When you play on a computer, they’re tracked.

When you play face to face, they’re “tracked”.

The only thing I’ve ever seen a real face-to-face DM actually track were the number of slices of pizza left in the box.

Belkar got his dagger back because that’s just how the D&D universe works.
When I DM, I expect my players to honestly track all their own stuff, and when I am a player, I do likewise.