@ Berzeker Unit
You voted for the Erudite class in 3rd, when there is no actual Erudite class. Someone created its description then never designed any mechanics for it. Do you really believe that the phobiamancer so bad that a class which doesn’t exist is better than it?
As for why I didn’t like the Overlord... you just proved my point with that claim. Why would I want to play a class whose literal point is to ineffectively yell at people as the others take care of the action for them? I am not saying it’s a terrible concept, but you could have at least given the Overlord something to help in combat. Or at least spells. But it doesn’t really get a whole lot of anything for itself.