Yet another thread on Hilgya's alignment

[Rrmcklin]

I can see a Good person committing murder. Though depending on the reasons and how they react when confronted with the fact that, yes, it really was murder, will depend on whether that person stays good for much longer.

Being Good and is clearly not equivalent with only doing Good things.

But MartianInvader, I don't think what you're getting is that going "other worse people exist" doesn't mean that Hilgya can't be Evil. The alignments are pretty wide pools by necessity.

I'd also say that you're (deliberately or otherwise) downplaying Hilgya's actual actions and her motivations for them, but others have already said done that.