Quote Originally Posted by lio45 View Post
And I'm saying that the size of the net should be strictly determined by what we see in the comic, not worked out backwards from the fact we want at least a certain minimum number of contenders.

If the correct net - the one taking into account all the dealbreakers and the solid inescapable facts - is so narrow that we don't find anything, it simply means we haven't yet found the right creature.


Personally, I don't even think I'm "choosing" anything. Whether or not the Tower Scene sends the message that MitD is physically extraordinarily powerful isn't my choice. It's fact. Cold hard fact.

If the Tower Scene hadn't happened (and while at it, if the box/umbrella had been bigger), then yeah, your "glowing yellow eyes contender with Wish" would likely be at the top of the running right now.

But it's not my fault or my "choice" that it isn't. It's just how things are.
There is a creature with yellow eyes and wish?
Which one?