Oliver walks his way over to the guy, saying, "While yes, I do decide who deserves it, I tend to do so by looking at how much they help others compared to how much they hurt others, as well as who they help and hurt." Stopping by the guy, he says, "However, I have the feeling that you guys will show me why that could be wrong, and hey, if I can be redeemed once in my life I can certainly be redeemed again." The first part, explaining how he decides who's deserving and suspecting that they'll show him why it could be wrong, is true. The redemption comment is also true, but Oliver doesn't think he needs redeeming a second time.