Looks like I'm in the minority, but I really like the "Few Zapped Pines" title. It's long (hopefully not long enough to lose a handful of characters when a "Re: " is placed in front of it), but I really like the implication that we forumites have arguments over the most minute details in the comic. Pokes a bit of fun at ourselves.
My second choice (have we considered Ranked Choice voting here?) would be the "Zapped Bananas" title.