Quote Originally Posted by paladinn View Post
Definitely not wanting all this. I prefer spell-less rangers and paladins. And the Pathfinder armor training really only works for melee fighters, especially tanks.

For "core" fighters, I'm thinking to allow the PB to be added to all damage for one weapon chosen at L1. And a 2nd Wind-type ability to regain some hp X times per day.
As someone who really likes 5E... This seems like a misguided attempt to shoehorn in something from another system.

Fighters could just get an ability where they add +X to their weapon damage rolls-say, one third Fighter levels (rounding down).
They could also just get Second Wind-once per day at level one, they can regain 1d10+Fighter level HP. Get another use at level 5, then another at 10, 15, and 20.

I also would NOT add "Can only use on one weapon," without also adding something like the Warblade's Weapon Aptitude.