I keep a running log on page one of this OOC thread. It is like the third post down and reads:


This is being saved for party information like XP logs, party treasure, etc.

598 C.Y.
Readying 20: (Womtham)
+ Hired by Captain Largent to take food to Sir Laurel Boomgren at Big Rapids
+ defended warehouse from 2 rat swarms and 8 wererat thieves
+ 800 XP; 17gp and 14sp total in coin (+38 gp for selling rapiers and light crossbow).
+ 8 potions of heroism from Opa for dealing with wererat thieves

Readying 21:
+ Party joined crew of Wavemistress to head to Big Rapids (a 2 day trip)

Readying 22:
+ Smoke is seen in direction of Big Rapids - party is sent to investigate using longboat


To answer your question more clearly, everyone should be at 3800xp (since everyone got 800xp). I just keep a running total of gold and treasure, since you may wish to have one person have more than one potion for instance.