Justified? No way. Commander's a real jerkhole. A funny jerkhole but a jerkhole none the less.

Gotta say I was pretty disgusted by it... those were not the actions of any good-aligned being.
Yeah... I kinda think that's the point. The Commander isn't Good. The act of killing a helpless prisoner is... grey to say the least, but the way he went about it was rather sadistic. Probably Evil, but I'm sure that's debatable


I'm disappointed with OOtS-verse elves. So far there have been hints that they simply aren't up to their own reputation.
What reputation do OOTS-verse Elves have, anyway?