Why Pun-Pun Doesn't Work

[Connington]

You probably didn't intend it that way, but this can be taken as very insulting to DMs that have run games with Pun-Pun in them.

I could amend that to take the long form.

Any DM that allows Pun-Pun in their game either lacks common sense, is dangerously passive, lacks a reasonably complete understanding of the mechanics of DnD, or is running a joke campaign and doesn't care.

Basically, what senrath said.

Anyways, this hasn't really been a fruitful discussion. Every one agrees that no player could get away with Pun-Pun at the table. The argument seems to be over whether something can work in theory but not in practice, which seems pretty obvious to me.