...I'm not touching the claim situation with a 99 1/2 foot pole, Not enough info. We can debate around in circles, but until we have actual proof for or against either one of them/something else happens, it would end up just being circles.
However, I have to say that some of the bandwagons that have been popping up around the situation have been pretty suspicious, mainly the ramsus one. However, bruntonspall attempting to reveal a potential hidden seer strikes me as more suspicious then anything else right now.