Witchunt V1.0 (WW Variant)

[Sotek]

That puts Tydude at 6 of the 7 votes, now, goodness.

------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! (13 alive, so 7 is lynch, 7 is sufficient to force nolynch)

Tydude: 6 (Murska, Aemoh, Sotek, Internet Flea, Ramsus, InaVegt)
VA_beds: 3 (Tydude, Eternal Drifter, lostlittlebear)
Sotek: 2 (VA_beds, Fleeing Coward)

------------------------

[InaVegt]

That puts Tydude at 6 of the 7 votes, now, goodness.

------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! (13 alive, so 7 is lynch, 7 is sufficient to force nolynch)

Tydude: 6 (Murska, Aemoh, Sotek, Internet Flea, Ramsus, InaVegt)
VA_beds: 3 (Tydude, Eternal Drifter, lostlittlebear)
Sotek: 2 (VA_beds, Fleeing Coward)

------------------------

Seven, actually.

[Tydude]

I'll change my vote to Sotek in an effort to save myself.

[Sotek]

Seven, actually.

Oh whoops, so it does, I missed Istari. Wow.

[Internet Flea]

I'll change my vote to Sotek in an effort to save myself.

Too late; there's already a majority. However, there is still a way.
VA Beds, please take charge of this and lynch Inavegt; she just cast the killing vote against Tydude before he could defend himself, so I expect she's really a witch.

[Sotek]

VA Beds, please take charge of this and lynch Inavegt; she just cast the killing vote against Tydude before he could defend himself, so I expect she's really a witch.

The drawback of this plan is that she's liable to be enchantress or warlock. Warlock we need to lynch, enchantress is a waste. I think we need to start talking about popping the lovers soon, btw. but I guess we can save that till the next day.

[Internet Flea]

I think it's still the best option, unless a lover wants to step forward. Or a softer witch.

[Sotek]

I think it's still the best option, unless a lover wants to step forward. Or a softer witch.

Yeah, not really arguing, I'm just a natural disputant.
Of course, that assumes VA_beds will even see the thread before it's too late to override, but maybe Milski will ask him?

[Milskidasith]

Well, you guys reached a majority. Unlike WW or Martyr, Leeroy doesn't get to react to a lynch, especially not when he was (presumably) on for the lynching time.

Tydude is dead.

Night 3 has begun!

[Milskidasith]

DAY 4 HAS BEGUN

Today's Soundtrack

As the group bickered and argued, Sotek was forcefully shoved into a one way time machine and sent thousands of years into the future.



"Well, looks like he's gone. Sucks for him." Istari said this, completely deadpan.

"At least there are less people to sort through now." said VA_Beds.

Suddenly, the forward time machine reappears, Sotek stepping out of it with a six pack in hand.

"Anybody want some booze?"

Sotek was targeted but survived the night. Day 4 has begun.

[CitizenFry]

Well, unless Sotek is head of the MOST DEVIOUS COVEN EVER, this pretty much locks him in as town.

[Sotek]

So, I wrote up an analysis post on my assumption that someone was going to die. Under that assumption, there are a lot of possible worlds in which we are already checkmated.

It's not quite accurate now, since, well, I was the one targetted, so we've got 12 alive still.

That said, the short version: If the spy replaced a squishy witch, we're probably dead, if he replaced enchantress we're ok if we hit a squishy witch already, if he replaced warlock we're ok if we hit two squishy witches already ...

... but we can't really afford more mislynches because we know we haven't targetted any of the tanky witches, so my math is suggesting the spy needs to claim - remember, spy, if you're not the enchantress we're (probably) going to lose three townies when we lynch the lovers. If the Spy is the JW, well, that complicates matters a bit more, and if the spy is dead we're screwed. Likewise, I could be underestimating what we've done to the witches, in which case the spy would know and be able to decide to stay quiet.

On a related note, we need to know who the lovers are - if we hit the enchantress we're gonna fall behind in numbers and it's really really close already.

Also, InaVegt, your gambit: explain it now, please. I'll hold off on voting you for a few, but it needs some explanation.

[InaVegt]

I was trying to draw forth some information based on people's re(actions) to my claim, with me giving as little info as needed.

I didn't get the info I wanted, and as such, it failed.

This game is proving exceedingly hard for me to analyse, which means it's no fun to actively play. As such, I'll be converting to sheep mode.

[Sotek]

[QUOTE=InaVegt;9324885This game is proving exceedingly hard for me to analyse, which means it's no fun to actively play. As such, I'll be converting to sheep mode.[/QUOTE]

That's because almost nobody is actively playing! There's nothing here to analyze, argh.

[Internet Flea]

Inavegt, unless we get a better target.
Claim reactions don't explain the sudden Tydude lynch.

[InaVegt]

Inavegt, unless we get a better target.
Claim reactions don't explain the sudden Tydude lynch.

Why? I only realised -after- I put in the lynching vote that I put in the lynching vote. An error, I'll admit. I'm not perfect, after all.

[Milskidasith]

That makes two of three lynches that people have claimed they didn't bother to check the thread before posting. This is fast becoming an recurring lie/theme. Use the preview post option, people.

Also, yes, this game is very inactive relative to most games. There's nothing to analyze because there has been only one claim, and it's by somebody who apparently expects to post once a real life day.

[Milskidasith]

Ramsus has died. No PMing means no PMing. If anybody else has any PMs, please forward them to me.

EDIT: Not all PMs are game relevant. If they are, then the consequences will be unpleasant. If it is a PM about the game, but without info/asking for info, it may be OK; private discussions along the lines of "this is crazy" or whatever are fine, but I'd err on the side of caution.

PM so the info is public:

Hey, well if you're one of the Witches you already know I'm one of the lovers, if not you're on our side. Unfortunately the other lover Aemoh is someone we really don't want to die right now. So I suppose if Aemoh does get lynched or die soon I'll at least know you're a witch.

[Sotek]

I think we really cannot afford to risk lynching someone other than the lovers right now - if we hit the enchantress we're screwed.

We most likely have the martyr still alive, though - he's permitted to go off on death, if I remember the rules correctly, so if one of the lovers is an important role, we can lynch the other one and have the martyr save the important one.

[InaVegt]

Also, yes, this game is very inactive relative to most games. There's nothing to analyze because there has been only one claim, and it's by somebody who apparently expects to post once a real life day.

I'm sorry. Some of us live in Europe AND have daily activities to attend to. I post whenever I'm able, but if that's not enough for you, I'm out.

[Sotek]

OK update in response to the PM being posted: Presuming it's true, well, that kind of helps us, actually.

it means the martyr is still up and kicking and we're ahead of matters by an NK.

... yeesh. WELL OK I guess we can possibly afford a mislynch.

Also, the spy still needs to think about claiming. Numbers are a bit better now because we don't need to pop the lovers, but...

[Milskidasith]

Inavegt, you have posted fairly often, at least relative to the other players. The "once per day" thing was directed at VA_Beds.

[Sotek]

I'm sorry. Some of us live in Europe AND have daily activities to attend to. I post whenever I'm able, but if that's not enough for you, I'm out.

pretty sure he meant VA_beds, although, yes, he miscounted claims there.

[Milskidasith]

EDIT: Yeah, I miscounted claims, sorry. I'm kind of angry-posting right now, which doesn't help my mind.

[Istari]

Well I suppose the thing to do now is for Aemoh to show up and verify or debunk the pm

[Sotek]

Well I suppose the thing to do now is for Aemoh to show up and verify or debunk the pm

I agree with this. I am not voting anyone till we hear from Aemoh and/or the spy. Well, or until enough time passes.

------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! (11 alive, so 6 is lynch, 6 is sufficient to force nolynch)

InaVegt: 1 (Internet Flea)

------------------------

[Ramsus]

I'm sorry what? The lovers isn't a role I can claim?

[InaVegt]

I'm sorry what? The lovers isn't a role I can claim?

All conversations must be in public.

[Milskidasith]

I'm sorry what? The lovers isn't a role I can claim?

There's a strict no PMing rule. PMing other players subverts the entire design of the game, and is against the rules for a very good reason. I ask you do not continue to post in this thread. If you wish, you can still participate in the GA votes.

[Ramsus]

"Anyone may at any time claim to be any role in the above communication, publicly or privately". That line right there is confusing. Whatever, you probably would have kicked be out anyway for accidentally editing a post to fix a typo before I remembered I couldn't do that either.