The Dragonspire Killers

[52.5 Lemons]

Wow. A four-way tie...

[Mindfreak]

Well, it seems a lot of you have made up your minds. Would you like me to accelerate to night this one time?

[ZarethG]

Yes! Do it while there's still a tie!

Edit: Yeah, nevermind. It's best to wait.

[Zjoot]

I don't know...let's wait a bit longer for Xan and C'nor first. (although this four way tie thing is pretty cool.)

[52.5 Lemons]

No. Do the full time, best to let those who havnt voted yet have a chance

[flabort]

Full time, some of us may still change our votes yet, and some others still have not voted, I think. I'm fairly set, I think, but as we unearth more clues from the kill...

[Lady Serpentine]

VotingC'nor, since I don't like any of the tied people as a killer.

[Mindfreak]

Everyone is chanting for blood, except they don't seem satisfied with one person! Groups of people are getting angry at others, resulting in a four-way tie!*

Day 2

{table=head]Name|Votes
52.5 Lemons|0
Atreyu the Masked LLama|0
C'nor|1
flabort|0
Gray Mage|3
Penguinator|3
Ramsus|0
Stopwatch|3
The Grimmace|0
TigerFang|0
usourselves&we|0
Xanmyral|0
ZarethG|0
Zefir|3[/table]

Who hasn't voted: Xanmyral.

Just 24 more hours until the lynching begins...

[usourselves&we]

And here I thought it had already been 48 hours, time is messing with me or something.

[ZarethG]

And here I thought it had already been 48 hours, time is messing with me or something.

Huh. Me, too. Weird.

[Penguinator]

Gray Mage. I see no logic behind stopwatch or myself, and I'm dubious of Zefir as a wolf.

In fact, I'm not seeing much logic for anybody here, today. Crazy sheep.

[Gray Mage]

Gray Mage. I see no logic behind stopwatch or myself, and I'm dubious of Zefir as a wolf.

In fact, I'm not seeing much logic for anybody here, today. Crazy sheep.

Amazing how this managed to put me up for lynch and take Zefir away from it in one go.

Anyway, it's not so much logic, but I figure there's a 50% chance of Zefir being a killer, if you know what I mean. I figured I'd say this now because I most likely won't be able to post until after the day ends.
PS: Yes, I'm claiming to have the other MG and scried Zefir, if that was not clear.

[usourselves&we]

As Mage had said, it’s odd to break a four way tie.
But I guess you like 1/2, better than 1/4.
Penguinator

[52.5 Lemons]

Gray Mage. I see no logic behind stopwatch or myself, and I'm dubious of Zefir as a wolf.

In fact, I'm not seeing much logic for anybody here, today. Crazy sheep.

None at all? Not even the red hankercheif with white polka dots? and for Stopwatch, what about the part with the golden pocket watch?

To me it seams as though you get more and more suspicious with every post you make. Im forced now to change my vote to Penguinator.

[Zjoot]

But honestly there's not much from the first night to point towards Penguinator. Although saving Zefir from the tie makes you look fairly guilty if he turns out to be evil (and vice versa.) For now, I'll follow Gray Mage's possible scry and change my vote to Zefir.

[Penguinator]

Fine, get me out of this game. Penguinator.

You're never going to win if you don't start thinking critically.

...Just be good to my dog.

And no, I wasn't saving Zefir, if I could've voted twice and shoved him into the lynching, I would have. But nobody seemed inclined to help with that, now did they?

I guess my other suspicion is Lemons.

[ZarethG]

Ok, wait. I know this'll make it sound like I'm a henchman if he is evil (which I'm not), but what's the clue from the first night for Penguinator? I, for one, don't see one.

Stopwatch, Gray Mage, and Zefir are the suspects I'm seeing right now.

Of course, maybe I'm horribly wrong.

[usourselves&we]

Fine, get me out of this game. Penguinator.

You're never going to win if you don't start thinking critically.

...Just be good to my dog.

And no, I wasn't saving Zefir, if I could've voted twice and shoved him into the lynching, I would have. But nobody seemed inclined to help with that, now did they?

I guess my other suspicion is Lemons.

I just wanted to see how that four way would have resolved, why doesn’t anyone like random chance?

I admit that ‘finch’ thing is dubious, but it’s still a clue (or whatever). And in the hopes of giving your dog a good home I'll keep my vote, have you sent him out before?

[Penguinator]

No. The way I understood it was that I got one use on five people and it remained dubious as to what happened. I guess that's not quite right, and I probably should have used it last night.

[Atreyu the Masked LLama]

On one hoof, I really did pick Penguinator at random and seem rather appalled that I have an ability to get him lynched accidentally in multiple games. In fact, I was pondering how to correct my error and save him.

On the other hoof, the fact that he seems to become suicidal doesn't do him any favors and makes it difficult to rescue him.

On the other hoof, (good think I'm a quadruped) there doesn't seem to be much in the way of clues to convict him and the sudden push to get him seem to indicate that maybe some henchies are trying to off the noble flightless bird.

On the last hoof, I have a 60% chance of being wrong whenever I do use deductive reasoning, so if I assume he's innocent, he's probably guilty.

I point at Zefir because I want to see what the dog does.

[Penguinator]

On the other hoof, the fact that he seems to become suicidal doesn't do him any favors and makes it difficult to rescue him.

I know. ...I fight harder when I'm a wolf, to be honest. Just look at City of Shadows.

I'll go back to Zefir, since Gray Mage seems to be implying that he's a killer. It's probably not worth it, but... whatever.

[Ramsus]

Ok switching to Penguinator. There's something mighty suspicious about Atreyu giving logic for why he should be pointing at Penguinator and pointing at Zefir instead. Also, I don't trust anyone who does the suicidal vote. And I trust them even less when someone conveniently makes them able to not die and they switch their vote.

I probably wouldn't do this anyway though if I didn't think Zefir just wasn't a killer. I really doubt he's the one writing those kills and I would be surprised if he managed to have the time to get someone else on his team to write it for him on night 0.

[Penguinator]

PS: Yes, I'm claiming to have the other MG and scried Zefir, if that was not clear.

...You people are blind.

[usourselves&we]

But if blades item was passed wouldn’t that mean something? Or did Mindfreak secretly destroy it?

Another thing, a lot of hints were pointing at blade before he was offed, maybe the lynch survivor is the next target?

[52.5 Lemons]

wow. upon re-reading my posts from yesterday I realize that any clue pointing towards penguinator in Day 1's kills really aren't likely to be clues at all. Not even "red herrings"; just coincidences.

I do see lots of evidence pointing towards Zefir from both days, however they seam too obvious. There does come a point however, when a clue is so obvious that it could even be made obvious as a way of misleading everyone.

I find the evidence pointing towards Stopwatch to be a much better candidate. I'm also a bit suspicious of Flabort.

EDIT: also, does anyone have an updated vote count? I have lost track of the votes so far.

[flabort]

{table]Stopwatch|Lemons, Flabort|2
Penguinator|Ramsus, usourselves&we, TigerFang, Zefir|4
Zefir|Penguinator, Llama, Grimmace, Stopwatch, Gray Mage|5
C'nor|C'nor|1
Gray Mage|ZarethG|1[/table]

So much for the tie

It's probably better this way. I don't think letting the RNG decide anyone's fate is the way to go.

[Ramsus]

@Penguinator: Oh, I totally missed that. Zefir then.

[usourselves&we]

Ok so calling people dim makes them change their vote?

It’s just as likely a scenario that mage is evil and is trying to strike down the angel (Zefir in this case). Anyone can claim to have a glass, it doesn’t mean you should follow them blindly.

[52.5 Lemons]

Ok so calling people dim makes them change their vote?

It’s just as likely a scenario that mage is evil and is trying to strike down the angel (Zefir in this case). Anyone can claim to have a glass, it doesn’t mean you should follow them blindly.

exactly. and even claiming that you have a glass just to make people vote for another person seams to me like something a henchman or killer might do.

[usourselves&we]

Rightly so, just look at what is happening.
6 votes on one person, because of a ‘50/50’ chance?