The Dragonspire Killers

[flabort]

Meh, I've been on all day and nothing's been going on. Shouldn't the murders be posted by now?

You missed them. We've been discussing who might be the killer again.

[stopwatch]

Dang, I got two votes too. Ouch.

Ok, I gathered 3 clues. (I'm kind of tired so my mind isn't fully functional.)
1. Golden pocket watch
2. Lemons on fish
3. White spotted handkerchief, which I personally see pointing to Penginator.
However, I believe these are all false clues, as they're too obvious. I know sometimes it is the obvious ones, but I think they hid the real clues good this time, just call it a hunch.
EDIT: I now see these clues have already been pointed out.
EDIT2: Ok, my vote is on Zefir. One, peingunator talked about the green stones, Zefir's avatar is 40% green stones. Two, if both killers teamed up on him, chances are he was onto them or something, guess who he voted for.

[Penguinator]

What page is Zefir's latest post? I need to see this.

Edit: Seen it. That's a lot of green stone/crystal. And since green stone/crystal is seen in both killings, it makes sense.

Re-Edit: Actually, it's just "gemstones" in the second. But the idea stands.

Grammer is my declared deadly enemy!

Plus, this makes me suspicious of all the misspellings in the killings.

[52.5 Lemons]

Meh, I've been on all day and nothing's been going on. Shouldn't the murders be posted by now?

Um..... They are posted, the killers worked together so there is only one. But like halfway down this page they are posted

[stopwatch]

What page is Zefir's latest post? I need to see this.

I saw only one of his posts, which is on page 1.
EDIT: I am doubtful that is his latest post though.

[Zjoot]

Last one I saw was him voting for bladescape.

[stopwatch]

Last one I saw was him voting for bladescape.

Hmm, was this before or after bladscape voted for him?

[Penguinator]

Well, I've seen his avatar, now.

And his signature.

[52.5 Lemons]

So, I'm assuming that whoever got blade's item has been pm'd about it?

[stopwatch]

That's my guess.

@V: Grammar and spell check?

[Zjoot]

Although unless one of the henchmen wrote his kills for him, his lack of understanding of grammar makes it unlikely that Zefir's a killer.

[Penguinator]

Although unless one of the henchmen wrote his kills for him, his lack of understanding of grammar makes it unlikely that he's a killer.

And then I realized that the less-correct grammar isn't in the same killing as the one mentioning green crystal. So, I'm confused, now.

[stopwatch]

Another thought, what if they disscussed it and the one better at spelling wrote it and PM'd it to Mind Freak?
EDIT: Dang bad reading.

[Zjoot]

Oh, I just noticed this post:

This may kick me in the butt later, but I'm curious. What in the first day's clues would point to me?

Well, the word Finch in the name has a connection to you, and the scar/tattoo thing could be interpreted as belonging to you. Those both seem very unlikely however. I really don't think you or stopwatch is a killer, but it's possible that one of you is a very very clever one.

[Atreyu the Masked LLama]

The mask and multicolored hair sounds like Atreyu the Masked LLama but it looks like he hasn’t been around lately . . . though it could be a ploy was there a hidden hint for him last time?
.

Actually, 3 times he's clicked to visit this thread specifically and 3 times the servers have suddenly been "too busy." Its rather frustrating honestly. Now I'm behind in a VERY interesting game.

Sigh...well to not die, I'm gonna randomly point at Penguinator until I get this all straightened out.

[usourselves&we]

Actually, 3 times he's clicked to visit this thread specifically and 3 times the servers have suddenly been "too busy." Its rather frustrating honestly. Now I'm behind in a VERY interesting game.

Sigh...well to not die, I'm gonna randomly point at Penguinator until I get this all straightened out.

That is annoying. With me it’s the ‘backing up server, please wait 30 minutes’ screen or whatever it actually says.

And the lovely 503 Service Temporarily Unavailable, that I just got -_-

[Penguinator]

Sigh...well to not die, I'm gonna randomly point at Penguinator until I get this all straightened out.

Come, now. You saw what happened last time you voted for me.

Yes, that wonderful 503 error has hit me, as well.

[usourselves&we]

Pengi, you should know better than to threaten people in a game about paranoia. . .

[Penguinator]

It's not a threat. Last time (I think it's been the latest time) Atreyu pointed at me was My Little Pony WW. I was town, and told everybody to go ahead and lynch me since I had the most votes. They all thought I was actually evil and was using reverse psychology.

[usourselves&we]

Oh, well to people (me) that haven’t read that game yet, it sounded like a threat. Carry on then.

[Zefir]

Wait so I'm a killer because I hate Grammer. Nice trick Penguinator the others may not see your trick, but I do.

[Lady Serpentine]

Ok so raise your hands if you didn't expect to see Bladescape night killed.

So there's spelling errors again. So either this is someone who doesn't proofread or it's intentionally misleading. Which is no excuse really. C'mon, spellcheck is built right into most browsers isn't it? So I guess I'd lean more toward someone I'm not used to playing with.

All the clues I see seem fairly obvious, which is just....weird. Whoever it is doesn't seem to be trying to mislead us as to the intended targets unless there's something more subtle going on that I'm missing. Which means there probably is.

I'd go for Gray Mage again but, I started with that yesterday. I guess I'll go for Stopwatch. I have no confidence in this at all though. If C'nor has any insights I'd like to hear them (since his gut instinct was right yesterday).

Edit: @Penguinator: Yeah, that seems to be more or less how it works. You just get to know something based on the five people you chose.

And wow I got ninja'd by multiple people.

*Raises hand*

I doubt my insights are going to be correct for too much longer... Zefir and Flabort are the only people I've interacted with.

But, they're still here, so without further ado:

I don't think Zefir did it; his posts are rather distinctive, and that's not present in any of the kills we've seen so far.

That said, they have to have gotten their roles before they wrote it, so there was time to set it up so that the other one proofread his kill.

And, if the killers keep working together, while it's good for us in some ways (namely fewer night kills), it makes it harder to catch them on that basis, because the writing style will be different from either of theirs when they're writing alone.

I have nothing to say about Flabort, save that he could probably come up with weirder, and better hidden, clues.

(For one thing, none of the clues have yet involved doors sprouting out of nowhere.)

[flabort]

(For one thing, none of the clues have yet involved doors sprouting out of nowhere.)

Indeed. I see you've checked out the Simulation

[Lady Serpentine]

Yep. That was weird, though cool. (I believe I asked a question about it, in fact. Though you seem to have missed it...)

[Penguinator]

Wait so I'm a killer because I hate Grammer. Nice trick Penguinator the others may not see your trick, but I do.

No, it's mostly because there are gemstones and green crystals in the narrations.

The grammar, if you would care to spell it correctly, was just the tip of the iceberg. Then I realized that green crystals and the incorrect grammar were not in the same narration, and retracted that point.

So, in other words, you didn't read very carefully, did you? Wolves don't tend to read things very carefully, now do they? My point still goes to you, until I come up with a better target.

Edit: Blagh, Server Errors.

[stopwatch]

No, it's mostly because there are gemstones and green crystals in the narrations.

The grammar, if you would care to spell it correctly, was just the tip of the iceberg. Then I realized that green crystals and the incorrect grammar were not in the same narration, and retracted that point.

So, in other words, you didn't read very carefully, did you? Wolves don't tend to read things very carefully, now do they? My point still goes to you, until I come up with a better target.

Edit: Blagh, Server Errors.

Meh, I personally would excuse him for that on account of what time it was as I know what being tired can do to you, but I still think for other reasons it's him.

EDIT: Server errors, GITPG's worst enemy.

[Zefir]

Well I don't really had time to read all 3 pages of new posts is not something you read in a secound especially in a foreign language. Also my last test is tomorrow so focus goes there.

[usourselves&we]

Today’s count: names shortened again

Zefir: GM/ Pen/ stop/3
Stopwatch: flabort/ Ram/ me/3
Gray Mage: Grim/ lemons/ ZG/3
Penguinator: LLama/ Zefir/ TF/3

The vote switch is just to tie two of my big suspects.

Nonvotes: C’nor/ Xan/2
There’s still a few more hours people, come on and vote.

Edit: All hail the random generator, may it bless us this evening.
Edit2: now this is just ridiculous

[ZarethG]

Gray Mage. Three way tie!

[TigerFang]

Penguinator because why not?