MASS CHAOS I: Better Name Not Found

[Thematthew]

I shall turn my magical summoning poke upon Nozza now!

Clearly my power must be to force people to play...

[Ramsus]

Clearly my power must be to force people to play...

If I thought there was even a 1% of that working out as a real thing I would give someone that power in every game I run. /

[Logic]

If I thought there was even a 1% of that working out as a real thing I would give someone that power in every game I run. /

And that player would be killed on day or night 1. The universe always finds ways to balance itself out.

You apparently have a magic poke.

...so...many...jokes...
...PG-13...forum...

[ThePhantom]

Xihirli, for my vote

[igordragonian]

lynching someone, when thinking he is a third party?
That sound suspicious to me. I vote Elenna

[Xihirli]

Self-preservation on Generic-Guy.

[Ramsus]

Anti-Generic Guy getting lynched vote on Xihirli then. Sorry dude, I don't want a mason getting lynched.

[Kish]

Just to spell it out, Xihirli, if you have suspicions, or just think someone other than Generic-Guy isn't worse than no-suspicions-either-direction, point at them, not the claimed mason. I'd gladly jump off your wagon for my part, just not while it's you or Generic-Guy.

[Ramsus]

Kish makes a good point. Also there's another post so I can do my other vote on Xihirli. I'd be happy to move them around somewhere else that doesn't wind up with GG or myself getting lynched.

[Duck999]

I'm gonna go 24 more hours.

[Aventine]

Clearly my power must be to force people to play...

If I thought there was even a 1% of that working out as a real thing I would give someone that power in every game I run. /

And that player would be killed on day or night 1. The universe always finds ways to balance itself out.

Or that player would never show up and it would be impossible to find someone to step in as replacement.

You apparently have a magic poke.

...so...many...jokes...
...PG-13...forum...

Sigh. I meant that innocently, now it just sounds so very dirty. Don't make me start using bad "logic" puns as revenge...


I guess I don't have anything constructive to add. Claiming to be a mason, with the only other mason being dead already, is too convenient not to deserve a few funny looks, but unless we get a counter-claim we have to assume it's true. And I'm voting for Xihirli so I can't complain about that wagon.

[Kish]

How would someone who was not a mason know on Day 1 that Basic Villager translated to "mason"?

[Xihirli]

Just to spell it out, Xihirli, if you have suspicions, or just think someone other than Generic-Guy isn't worse than no-suspicions-either-direction, point at them, not the claimed mason. I'd gladly jump off your wagon for my part, just not while it's you or Generic-Guy.

I'm willing to go back to ThePhantom totally not out of spite for voting for me but because of no reasoning.

[Ramsus]

Ok then. I'll swap one of my votes over to thePhantom. I'll see about the other one if other people follow suit or otherwise put someone higher up in the running than GG.

[Aventine]

How would someone who was not a mason know on Day 1 that Basic Villager translated to "mason"?

Is this directed to me? Unless I completely missed it, nobody said anything about masons on Day 1. Generic-Guy's first claim to be a mason was today, after Duneyyr was dead. Nor do we know that the Basic Villager was, in fact, a mason. All we have is GG's word about it.

None of that matters, since if he's lying the real masons would have told us by now (one hopes), but GG's claim per se does not prove he is a mason, and certainly not because he claims Duneyyr was one as well.

[OrbitalPanic]

A cursory reading tells me that both the Xihirli and Generic-Guy wagons sound bad, so I guess ThePhantom.

[Thematthew]

I suppose I can get beThePhantom here, Mostly because I don't like the reasons given for the Xihirli wagon and G-G has the 'claimed mason' defense.

Also, magic poke failed.

[Kish]

ThePhantom it is then. Making him...tied with Xihirli. Hopefully, someone will break it.

[Ramsus]

And with that I shall now switch my other vote to thePhantom.

[Eggel]

Wait.

Why is everyone voting for thephantom all of a sudden?
Did I miss something?

[Duck999]

Day 2 Over

The second day came and went and the narrator couldn't think of anything to entertain his players with, so he decided to be lazy. A lot of stuff happened. Votes changed. People died. Not that last one though.

Spoiler: Results

Show

ThePhantom would have died, but he didn't.

Begin Night 2

[Xihirli]

So I'm not asking for a public explanation from Phantom, but if GG isn't a Mason we should get a counterclaim now and if none comes I think it would be best if Phantom contacts GG tonight about how he avoided being lynched and tomorrow we can hear whether or not we've gotten a satisfactory explanation from him.
Also, GG, feel free to tell me if there's anyone whose vote I should control tomorrow via Message.

[Duck999]

Night 2 Over.

Twinkle twinkle little liar,
I'd like you to die in a fire,
That explains what I just did,
ignited your house with you inside.
I don't care that didn't rhyme,
You are dead good night good bye.

Killers can't sing really well...

Spoiler: Results

Show

Elenna died. She was the Liar, evil.

Begin Day 3

[Kish]

Someone tried to kill me last night.

(Unless you can prove you're town, you don't need to know why "tried.")

[Elenna]

*giggles at narration*

Oh well. Good luck, wolves! *fades out with evil cackle, suddenly turning this into a B-list cliche movie*

[Duneyrr]

*fades in while eating pancakes on a giant eyeball, suddenly turning it into an experimental film*

Oh, I'm still dead!

*fades out again*

[flatfooted]

Ramsus

[Ramsus]

Flatfooted for making an overly wordy post.

[Grand Arbiter]

I'll poke Eggel for now. Nobody seems particularly wolfy to me.

Someone tried to kill me last night.

(Unless you can prove you're town, you don't need to know why "tried.")

...Wolf night-kill maybe?

[igordragonian]

Mind to explain Kish?