Results 1 to 30 of 61
-
2018-01-21, 07:29 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Lots of "Alignment" threads these past few months, and my post at the Favorite scene evar?, have made me feel like guessing and reading arguments of fictional characters D&D "Alignments" (ignoring that the traditional 9 points AD&D/WD&D "Alignment system" may not map multi-dimensiontional characters).
I'll let others pick "Alignments" for Batman, Daenerys Targaryen, Han Solo, Harry Dresden, etc (please do! )
Spoiler: Here's my picks:
(In no particular order)
From the Discworld novels
Tiffany Aching,
Neutral Good
Sam Vines,
Lawful Good
Lord Havelock Vetinari,
Lawful Evil, trending Lawful Neutral
Rick from Casablanca,
I'll peg as someone Neutral Good, trying to be Evil, but coming around again to being Good.
Tom Joad at the end of the Grapes of Wrath,
outside of Robin Hood, maybe one of the purest distillation of Chaotic Good in fiction.
Atticus Finch, from To Kill A Mockingbird,
is a quintessence of Lawful Good (thanks to a post of @Red Fel's for reminding me of this),
Conan,
Chaotic Neutral
Thulsa Doom in Conan the Barbarian,
Lawful Evil
Richard the 3rd in Richard lll,
Neutral Evil
Bruno Anthony in Strangers on a Train
Chaotic Evil
Harry Lime in The Third Man
Neutral Evil
Phyllis Dietrichson & Walter Neff in
Double Indemnity
Both Chaotic Evil
Now I'm going to do a bunch from one film, Excalibur:
Sir Perceval,
Lawful Good, and the true hero of the film, if I ever play an old-fashioned D&D Paladin, this will be the model
Uther Pendragon,
His step-daughter Morgana (they combined the characters of Morgan le Fay, and her sister Morgause for the film),
and her son Mordred
all Chaotic Evil
Mordred's father
King Arthur Pendragon
and his wife,
Queen Guinevere,
both, Neutral Good, yep that's right, argue with me!
Merlin,
I can't even guess.
A force of Chaos, that profeses Lawful aims.
Okay, please pick some fictional characters, peg them to an Alignment, or argue with previous choices.
Thanks!Last edited by 2D8HP; 2018-01-22 at 01:12 AM.
-
2018-01-22, 12:22 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
- Location
- The Chi
- Gender
Re: Guess and arguing fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
I haven’t had an alignment conversation in well over a year (mostly because they occur mostly in other forums than media) but over the last decade or so this forum has always teemed with them producing some of the most divisive and forum-rule breaking discussions to be had.
After seeing countless threads, the only conclusion (one that several people including the Giant has stated) is that the nine alignments are so vague that one can’t ever expect perfect agreement on what they mean and who should have what alignment.
I think this is especially true of law and chaos. People are also not used to thinking about morality in that way like they are in terms of “good” and “evil” so the ideas people have about what is lawful and chaotic vary quite a bit more. However, the text itself throws the law-chaos axis in contradictory directions. So many contradictory things are said about the axis that many actions might be indicative of either law or chaos. For example in the players handbook the Monk is lawful because of her dedication to her discipline but Mialee the Mage is neutral because of her dedication to her art. The words “discipline” and “art” however, are synonyms in English.
Finally, I’ve seen forum debate where James Bond was literally argued to be each of the 9 alignments.
After that I’m not sure alignment related discussions are all that valuable barring a specific D&D related purpose. Also, after seeing a ton of fictional character alignment charts, I wouldn’t put any stock in them.The laws of physics are not crying in a corner, they are bawling in the forums.
Thanks to half-halfling for the avatar
-
2018-01-22, 01:12 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Location
- where the wind blows
Re: Guess and arguing fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
SpoilerYou got Magic Mech in My Police Procedural!
In this forum, Gaming is Serious Business, and Anyone Can Die. Not even your status as the Ensemble Darkhorse can guarantee your survival.
Disciple of GITP Trope-Fu Temple And Captain of GITP Valkyrie Squadron.
Awesome Elizabeth Shelley by HollamerSpoiler
The OTP in the playground.
My Gallery/My Star Wolves 3 LP
-
2018-01-22, 02:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Well, here's a thought for this.
The D&D Cartoon.
What Alignments are the main character kids?"I Burn!"
-
2018-01-22, 08:14 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
.
Since they were under 1e AD&D rules, post Unearthed Arcana (which I read in the store, didn't like, and pretty much was the end of my buying D&D stuff), the Barbarian would have to be Chaotic (something), so probably Chaotic Good (if UA matches the Barbarian class from The Dragon article), the Thief would have to be (something) Neutral, Neutral (sometimg), or (somethimg) Evil, so probably Neutral Good, the Ranger would have to be (something) Good, and the Monk would have to be (Lawful) something, I don't remember the rules for Cavalier, and the Magic-User could be any alignment under the rules (weird how I still remember the class alignment restrictions decades after I played AD&D).
I was already a teenager (15 to 17 years old) during the shows run, and didn't watch all of it, or much Saturday morning cartoons at all during that time (unlike the earlier Thundar the Barbarian which I watched avidly).
But I'd say one Chaotic Good Barbarian, and the rest Lawful or Neutral Good.
-
2018-01-22, 04:20 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
- Location
- The Chi
- Gender
Re: Guess and arguing fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
The laws of physics are not crying in a corner, they are bawling in the forums.
Thanks to half-halfling for the avatar
-
2018-01-23, 12:59 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2006
- Location
- where the wind blows
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Fair, the evil one is Crazy Steve pretending to be batman
(it's referring to the theory that the batman in Frank miller's all star batman is a crazy hobo who found batman costume)You got Magic Mech in My Police Procedural!
In this forum, Gaming is Serious Business, and Anyone Can Die. Not even your status as the Ensemble Darkhorse can guarantee your survival.
Disciple of GITP Trope-Fu Temple And Captain of GITP Valkyrie Squadron.
Awesome Elizabeth Shelley by HollamerSpoiler
The OTP in the playground.
My Gallery/My Star Wolves 3 LP
-
2018-01-23, 03:38 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
-
2018-01-23, 04:18 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2006
- Location
- Under Mt. Ebott
- Gender
Re: Guess and arguing fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Last edited by Drascin; 2018-01-23 at 04:18 AM.
-
2018-01-23, 04:47 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Switzerland
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
I don't see how you can argue Harry Dresden to be anything but Chaotic Good. He's sarcastic about it occasionally, but I don't have any doubt about it.
Just see him opposite any authority figure. He pisses them off on purpose and enjoys it greatly. On the other hand, strong personal loyalties to people he respects. Entirely too willing to break laws and rules, occasionally lie and cheat, even to his best and most respected friends.
Messiah complex the size of the planet. Self-sacrifices all over for other people. Did... things (spoilers) because he thought he might potentially turn evil. Tries to help everyone he meets, especially anyone he sees as weak or innocent. Goes ballistic when children are concerned.Resident Vancian Apologist
-
2018-01-23, 02:39 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
- Location
- The Chi
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Those versions aren't "Batman" they are distinctly separate fiction characters that might have the name as well as being Batman's alternative Earth doppelgänger.
An evil act does not (usually) automatically shift a character's alignment.
Moreover, by your own explanation, writers who on occasion write Batman in ways consistent with lawful evil don't understand or "GET" the character. You yourself assume there is a singular "character" that can be gotten and that character is not lawful evil.The laws of physics are not crying in a corner, they are bawling in the forums.
Thanks to half-halfling for the avatar
-
2018-01-23, 03:06 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2012
Proudly addicted to pointing out where exactly rules can be found.
Countdown to Belkar's death and my follow-up count gives us less then 3 weeks left. Poor Belkar.
Avatar by Akrim.elf
___
What effects allow a saving throw?
List of almost all 3.5 skills.
Old PF Initiative Build
-
2018-01-23, 03:25 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Man, Dresden is Lawful Neutral. Although the lawful part... is pretty loose. lol
While he isn't outright evil. He has to much stain on his soul to be considered gud. To willing to do the things you aren't suppose to do to get the job done. However he does have a lot of rules that he follows and doesn't break. If he says he will do something, he will get it done. for the most part. Again, being lawful doesn't mean you follow every rule, just that you follow a set of rules you will not break. Also, he does respect the laws of others as long as they don't get in his way.
-
2018-01-23, 03:42 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Location
- ICU, under a cherry tree.
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Castlevania II: Dracula's Curse
Sabian Skellegue, the Unyielding Wrath
IC OOC
Expedition to Castle Ravenloft
Aelki Ruasha, Void Knight of the Star Ocean
IC OOC MAP
Chult Hex Crawl
Ondros, Mazewalker of Ubtao
IC OOC Slide Deck
Retired Characters
-
2018-01-23, 04:26 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
- Location
- Toledo, Ohio
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Well, he did spend several years communing with a fallen angel and channeling the power of Hell itself, is bound to the service of a fairly wicked fairy, and has dabbled with multiple forms of black magic. Not to mention the genocide.
I don't think it is enough to push him all the way from Good to Neutral (it takes a lot of moral fiber to threaten a literal angel of death in a misguided attempt to protect a good man), but by Skin Game he's wandered pretty close to that line.
I do agree that he's much more Lawful (his own internal code is extremely strict, and much of his knee-jerk rejection of authority is due to the number of authorities he's met that don't live up to his standards) than he is Chaotic. Depending on how you rate his actions, he's somewhere at the border of Lawful Neutral, Lawful Good, and True Neutral.
-
2018-01-23, 04:50 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2009
- Location
- Birmingham, AL
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Fun fact! The DVD set contains a booklet that has, among other things, the full character stats for everyone! It looks like the stats are for 3.5 edition (the current edition at the time of DVD set release), but I dunno, I've never played any previous version. Enjoy:
Spoiler: Short version, Venger should have killed them all in every episode.
Hank Human Male Ranger 7th AL: LG
S: 14 D: 17 C: 15 I: 10 W: 15 Ch: 18 HP: 49
Feats: Dodge, Endurance, Manyshot, Point Blank Shot, Precise Shot, Rapid Shot, Track, Weapon Focus (Longbow)
Equip: +3 Studded Leather, Energy Bow (+2 Composite Longbow that accommodates any strength, force arrows deal 2d6 and ignore miss chance for incorporeal, shed light as a torch, can make power shots with Hank taking a negative to attack and adding that number to damage), Amulet of Natural Armor +1, lesser bracers of archery, ring of protection +1, masterwork longsword, potion of cure light wounds, potion of resist cold 20, some normal gear
Eric Male Human Fighter 7th AL: NG
S: 18 D: 13 C: 14 I: 13 W: 10 Ch: 9 HP: 57
Feats: Combat Expertise, Improved Disarm, Improved Initiative, Improved Shield Bash, Lightning Reflexes, Run, Weapon Focus (Shield), Weapon Specialization (Shield)
Equip: +2 Elven Chain, Griffon Shield (+2 Bashing Heavy Steel Shield that can be wielded two handed, as an immediate action can create a 10ft diameter Otiluke's Resilient Sphere centered on Eric, any other creature in the area may make a Reflex save DC16 to be pushed into the nearest open square on a success, effect can be dismissed as a standard action or until the duration elapses. The sphere effect may be used for 5 rounds per day which need not be consecutive.), Bag of holding (type I), cloak of resistance +2, gauntlets of ogre power +2, potion of cure moderate wounds, some normal gear.
Diana Human Female Monk 7th AL: LG
S: 14 D: 17 C: 16 I: 13 W: 17 Ch: 13 HP: 56
Feats: Combat Reflexes, Improved Trip, Lightning Reflexes, Stunning Fist, Weapon Finesse, Weapon Focus (Quarterstaff), Weapon Focus (Unarmed Strike)
Equip: Javelin Staff (+2 ki strike quarterstaff when used in melee or +2 ki strike javelin when thrown, allows use of stunning fist in melee or at range, can extend to 20 feet or shrink to the size of a toothpick as a standard action but can not be used as a weapon in either form, +5 bonus to jump checks, Diana may make a free trip attack whenever the staff hits someone without provoking attacks of opportunity and if the attempt fails the opponent may not attempt to trip Diana), amulet of natural armor +1, bracers of armor +3, ring of protection +1, vest of escape, potion of cure serious wounds, some normal gear.
Presto Human Male Wizard 7th AL: NG
S: 11 D: 9 C: 16 I: 20 W: 15 Ch: 13 HP: 40
Feats: Combat Casting, Empower Spell, Lightning Reflexes, Magical Aptitude, Scribe Scroll, Spell Focus (Evocation)
Equip: dagger, Hat of Many Spells (acts as a rod of wonder, Presto can reach into the hat and produce any spell component up to 1000 gp for any spell he casts (component lasts 1 round), use the hat to Empower a spell he is casting or cast a spell directly from his spellbook but these effects can be unpredictable - roll percentile dice: on 1 - 35 the spell is wasted but a rod of wonder effect occurs, 36 - 65 the spell takes effect but a rod of wonder effect occurs as well, 66 - 100 the spell takes effect as desired.), Amulet of Natural Armor +1, cloak of resistance +2, headband of intellect +2, ring of protection +1, spellbook, potion of aid, potion of cure serious wounds, potion of displacement, wand of magic missile (7th), some normal gear
Sheila Human Female Rogue 7th AL: NG
S: 10 D: 18 C: 17 I: 14 W: 13 Ch: 15 HP: 48
Feats: Skill Focus (Use Magic Device), Two Weapon Fighting, Weapon Finesse, Weapon Focus (Rapier)
Equip: +2 Mithral Shirt, ring of protection +1, two masterwork rapiers, Cloak of Invisibility (Invisibility as the spell 5/day, greater invisibility 2/day for 1d4 rounds, Sheila needs a free hand to activate the cloak, if damaged while invisible Sheila becomes visible and the cloak stops functioning for 2d4 rounds), potion of cure moderate wounds, scroll of raise dead, scroll of sanctuary, wand of cure moderate wounds (25 charges), some normal gear
Bobby Human Male Barbarian 7th AL: CG
S: 19 D: 13 C: 18 I: 11 W: 8 Ch: 10 HP: 79
Feats: Cleave, Improved Sunder, Power Attack, Weapon Focus (Greatclub)
Equip: Thunder Club (+2 greatclub, grants +4 Strength, 3/day Bobby may strike the ground and cause a tremor in a 30 foot line those in the area must make a Reflex DC 20 or fall prone), +2 hide armor, amulet of natural armor +2, boots of the winterlands, potion of cure light wounds, potion of heroism, salve of slipperiness, sovereign glue, universal solvent, some normal gear
Uni 3HD Young Unicorn (Small Magical Beast) AL: LG CR: 2
S: 10 D: 17 C: 21 I: 10 W: 16 Ch: 17 HP: 31
Feats: Alertness, Skill Focus (Survival)
SA/SQ: Magic Circle against Evil 10 radius; immune to charm, compulsion, and poison; alicorn (Uni's horn is treated as +1 magic weapon); darkvision 60 feet; lowlight vision; scent
Spell like abilities: Cure light wounds 3/day, cure moderate wounds 1/day, neutralize poison (touch only DC 17) 1/day, greater teleport (within forest only) 1/day (caster Level 5th)
Venger Male Half Fiend Human Sorcerer 13th/ Archmage 5th AL: NE
S: 18 D: 22 C: 26 I: 18 W: 15 Ch: 24 HP: 190
Feats: Empower Spell, Great Fortitude, Iron Will, Lighting Reflexes, Skill Focus (Spellcraft), Spell Focus (Evocation), Spell Focus (Necromancy), Weapon Focus (Ray)
Equip: Amulet of Health +6, Bracers of Armor +8, Cape of Montebank, Bead of Force, Elemental Gem (Fire), Maximize Metamagic Rod, Potion of Barkskin +3, Potion of Cat's Grace
High Arcana: Arcane Fire, Arcane Reach, Mastery of Elements, Mastery of Shaping, Spell Power +1
Sorcerer Spells Known: (Caster Level 19)
0th (6/day): arcane mark, detect magic, ghost sound, light, mage hand, open/close, read magic, resistance, touch of fatigue
1st (8/day): expeditious retreat, magic missile, protection from good, ray of enfeeblement, shield
2nd (8/day): Knock, false life, scorching ray, touch of idiocy, web
3rd (8/day): dispel magic, displacement, fireball, hold person
4th (7/day): animate dead, bestow curse, polymorph, wall of ice
5th (6/day): cone of cold, symbol of pain, telekinesis, wall of force
6th (6/day): chain lightning, flesh to stone, Otiluke's freezing sphere
7th (6/day): control undead, delayed blast fireball, limited wish
8th (4/day): Otiluke's Telekinetic Sphere, polar ray
9th (2/day): Imprisonment
Also, obviously, the Dungeon Master is a Cheese Elemental.Cuthalion's art is the prettiest art of all the art. Like my avatar.
Number of times Roland St. Jude has sworn revenge upon me: 2
-
2018-01-23, 04:51 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Location
- ICU, under a cherry tree.
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Well, sure. But...
SpoilerHe was exposed to Lasciel's power because he was saving an innocent child from being exposed to and corrupted by her instead.
And then in those years that she was tempting him, he was so incorruptible that instead of Dresden turning to evil, she actually commits an act of self sacrifice to save him, rebelling against her evil nature instead.
So, I chalk this up to "Dresden is good".
is bound to the service of a fairly wicked fairy
SpoilerDresden could have always been bound to Mab. But he has resisted her offer time and time again. She, as an immortal, can simply wait him out, until he is so desperate that he comes to her for aid. Obviously, we see that happen in Changes. But it doesn't make him evil, or not good. He didn't serve her because he wants to be evil and wants the power she grants for the sake of being a tyrant over others. He serves her, yes, but he still has agency and still enacts her orders without being evil. They even say in Skin Game that Mab had Dresden get involved precisely because she could count on him to foil Nicodemus' plans.
and has dabbled with multiple forms of black magic.
Not to mention the genocide.SpoilerSo the destruction of monsters outweighs the liberation of entire nations of humans that up until that point were various levels of pawn, slave, chattel?
I don't think it is enough to push him all the way from Good to Neutral (it takes a lot of moral fiber to threaten a literal angel of death in a misguided attempt to protect a good man), but by Skin Game he's wandered pretty close to that line.SpoilerBy Skin Game, he appears to be all the things people are suspicious of him for, but as the reader we have a more intimate perspective and know why/how he was using Hellfire, why he is the Winter Knight, how it came to be that he eradicated an entire court of vampires, etc. It's not because he's evil, or borderline evil, or anything like that.
I do agree that he's much more Lawful (his own internal code is extremely strict, and much of his knee-jerk rejection of authority is due to the number of authorities he's met that don't live up to his standards) than he is Chaotic. Depending on how you rate his actions, he's somewhere at the border of Lawful Neutral, Lawful Good, and True Neutral.Castlevania II: Dracula's Curse
Sabian Skellegue, the Unyielding Wrath
IC OOC
Expedition to Castle Ravenloft
Aelki Ruasha, Void Knight of the Star Ocean
IC OOC MAP
Chult Hex Crawl
Ondros, Mazewalker of Ubtao
IC OOC Slide Deck
Retired Characters
-
2018-01-24, 01:44 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
The disconnect you are having, isn't that Dresden is an evil person, or borderline evil. He isn't. We know this, everyone around knows it, even his enemies know it. Inherently, yeah Dresden is a good person. Not in an alignment sense. The problem is that he doesn't see himself this way. This allows himself to LET himself do horrible acts. The thing is though, he KNOWS he is doing horrible acts, and doesn't try to lie to himself about it. What evil people do is do those acts, and then try to justify those actions.
Yes, he killed of a lot of horrible monsters. He didn't do it for good reasons. He didn't do it out of any sense of altruism. He did it cause they wronged him. He knows about all the horrible things in the world. He doesn't do anything about them, until they do something to him first.
-
2018-01-24, 02:27 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2010
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Agreed. Despite all his self-flagellation and deprecation, he does everything he does with goodness in mind without ever really actually going over any clear lines I can point to. He is solidly chaotic good despite him beating himself up about wielding powers that are labeled Evil(TM).
I mean lets remember that this entire series is narrated from Dresden's own self depreciating viewpoint about himself, and thus probably doesn't give himself enough credit. He is oddly similar to Ciaphas Cain in that regard. I mean The Knights of the Cross for whatever reason are still his allies and friends. I think that counts for a lot, because if he really stepped over a line, I'm pretty sure those guys would rightly turn against him. Furthermore, Uriel is still on his side. an angel. The black ops angel but an angel nonetheless. He really hasn't done anything I can really label as bad enough to be anything but good
I mean so far his "hellish powers" didn't involve doing anything evil to cast, his Winter Knight mantle is not reflective of alignment as its just some external magic thing put inside him rather than his actual morality, his T-rex stunt didn't really seem to affect his morality at all, and despite his whole "I'm going to burn the world to save my daughter" rant, the only people he ends up destroying are those Red Court jerks which no one sheds a tear for. I think we can safely say his professed "burn the world, I'm rescuing my daughter" thing and him talking about his plans for other deals is him speaking out of stress of the moment really, he never really did anything that truly crosses the line, like ok he got some primal magic sexytimes with Mab, who cares, like ok he killed the Red Court, awesome.
Like.....I guess some of this is somehow morally ambiguous if your being a complete knight templar about viewing his actions and think that somehow he could be gooderer than he already is, but all the actions he takes is reasonable and have had positive effects on the world while getting rid of truly horrible monsters, I can't ask for anything more good than that.
-
2018-01-24, 03:22 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2006
- Location
- Under Mt. Ebott
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
That is the joke of that poster, dude. That Batman's different writers have written him in such different ways that you can find runs that write him as basically every alignment.
Course, fans do have their own ideas. Hence wht Fri said - for example, Miller's Batman is memefied to not actually BE Batman, but a hobo in a Batman suit, because the way he acts is straight up Evil, and fans are like "um, I'm pretty sure Batman is not supposed to be like this". But the (actually pretty long!) run with Batman being more or less a pro-totalitarianism fascist ****head absolutely exists. Hence the poster.
-
2018-01-24, 03:53 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Switzerland
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
One of my personal metrics for lawful or chaotic is whether you respect a person in authority because of the "person" or the "authority" part more. "WE respect the king because he is the king" is lawful. "I respect the king because he's a good man" is chaotic. Following the rules you set for yourself, on the other hand, I don't really see as that lawful, though it can be an indication.
So, to me, Dresden is chaotic. But then, as we've seen, law and chaos are up to debate. I just made my own definition that I think mostly works for me.Resident Vancian Apologist
-
2018-01-24, 04:26 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2008
- Location
- Germany
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Honestly, I feel the lawful/chaotic distinction is way easier than the good/evil one if you don't want to stick to mere personal opinion. Of course there are a few people who consider themselves evil but for the majority they have some kind of reasoning why their actions are good, so in their own eyes they are good. Of course their opponents think differently but who are we to judge which side is correct? To go with an old popular argument : is the established government defending itself against terrorists good or is it the rebel alliance fighting the evil empire? Sure, blowing up a planet doesn't sound too nice but on a stellar scale it's akin to.. I just realized my comparison might be a little bit too close to real life politics. Let's just say it's not that destructive if there are millions of other planets.
-
2018-01-24, 05:30 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2010
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
morality is not about knowing, because we'll never have perfect information. its about being aware and not-knowing, and doing something about it because of the possibilities that could occur if we didn't do something. I can't imagine a galactic consequences of a single planet existing or not existing, but I can imagine the consequence of the planet itself: I can either imagine a future where that planet is all destroyed in a burst of searing, screaming agony from a horrible light as they are ripped to atoms, their last moments being pure burning torment on every part of their body, or I can imagine a future where the innocents, the children and all the people on there continue to live happy lives because I intervened. given those two possibilities, it is right to pick to defend the planet every time.
-
2018-01-24, 05:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
There is a flaw in that reasoning though.
You respect the man cause' he is King. sure law.
You respect the man cause he is a man.. that is neutral.
You don't care about the man. That is chaotic.
-
2018-01-24, 07:50 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
"You respect the man because he's done stuff that you think is enough to earn your respect" is a Chaotic reason for giving respect.
Alternatively:
"You respect the man because that's your default - you respect everybody until they lose your respect"
That's Drizzt's version (novel "Drizzt essay" on respect at the start of a section)- Drizzt being CG in most (all?) stattings.
According to Fiendish Codex 2 - obeying somebody you do not respect, is Lawful - an "Obesiant act" - textbook example of "respecting the office rather than the person".Last edited by hamishspence; 2018-01-24 at 07:51 AM.
Marut-2 Avatar by Serpentine
New Marut Avatar by Linkele
-
2018-01-24, 08:01 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2007
- Location
- Switzerland
- Gender
-
2018-01-24, 08:35 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2008
- Location
- Germany
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
How do you know their lives are going to be happy?
And if the planet is merely a base for an organization that plans to repeatedly attack the workplace of people merely doing their job for what the terrorists consider an evil regime? But OK, we know alderaan in all likelihood was just an ordinary planet. The question about the justification of Luke's mass murder when he blew up the Death Star remains. We could of course make the assumption that anyone who works for an evil empire must be evil but that seems simplistic to me. Or "they knew what they signed up for" but then we also give a pass to criminals hurting law enforcement officials and such.
-
2018-01-24, 09:46 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
The Death Star, despite the name "space station" is a warship. Blowing up a warship, in a "time of civil war" can hardly be deemed murder. Nor is it anything like blowing up a planet.
Starkiller Base is a bit more "planet-like" (it even has trees on its surface) but it's still a superweapon. Blowing it up is akin to, during a nuclear war, blowing up a city that happens to have nuclear silos within - a city that has already fired some of them once.
Whereas blowing up the Death Star, is like blowing up a ballistic missile submarine - again, one that has already acted as a combatant and fired some of its missiles.Last edited by hamishspence; 2018-01-24 at 09:50 AM.
Marut-2 Avatar by Serpentine
New Marut Avatar by Linkele
-
2018-01-24, 10:00 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2009
- Location
- Birmingham, AL
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
Cuthalion's art is the prettiest art of all the art. Like my avatar.
Number of times Roland St. Jude has sworn revenge upon me: 2
-
2018-01-24, 01:38 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Location
- ICU, under a cherry tree.
- Gender
Re: Guess and argue fictional characters D&D "Alignments"
You said he isn't outright evil. I thought you were implying that he's close to it. Am I wrong?
Inherently, yeah Dresden is a good person. Not in an alignment sense. The problem is that he doesn't see himself this way. This allows himself to LET himself do horrible acts. The thing is though, he KNOWS he is doing horrible acts, and doesn't try to lie to himself about it. What evil people do is do those acts, and then try to justify those actions.
Yes, he killed of a lot of horrible monsters. He didn't do it for good reasons. He didn't do it out of any sense of altruism. He did it cause they wronged him.
So was it personal for him that they went after his daughter? Yeah, it was. But were the actions he took after that altruistic? Yeah, I would argue they were. And I would argue that he didn't have to kill Susan on the altar with the sacrificial knife, but he knew that doing so would destroy the Red Court and alleviate an unimaginable amount of pain and suffering in the world, so he did.
He knows about all the horrible things in the world. He doesn't do anything about them, until they do something to him first.
There is a flaw in that reasoning though.
You respect the man cause' he is King. sure law.
You respect the man cause he is a man.. that is neutral.
You don't care about the man. That is chaotic.Castlevania II: Dracula's Curse
Sabian Skellegue, the Unyielding Wrath
IC OOC
Expedition to Castle Ravenloft
Aelki Ruasha, Void Knight of the Star Ocean
IC OOC MAP
Chult Hex Crawl
Ondros, Mazewalker of Ubtao
IC OOC Slide Deck
Retired Characters