Smalltown

[Saint Nil]

I DID bane shadowcaller. I even reminded Emperor Demonking about it and tried to make an automatic Team Evil win beause of the mistake.

[Shadowcaller]

Well Nale moved your bane to yourself.

[Saint Nil]

Ah. I appreciate the though Fin, but not very useful when I'm redcloak.

[Fleeing Coward]

Interesting game, some of the roles are probably abit overpowered but these things almost always happen in small games.
Hinjo's double vote could end the game in day 2 as Freshmeat pointed out. Roy is almost as bad since if he's on team evil and they all surivive to day 2, it's pretty much game over for the villagers too as he takes down a member of team good with him.
I picked Belkar purely with the intention of killing Roy if I ended up on team evil but when I got a villager role, I wasn't going to risk what could potentially be a night with 4 villager deaths or a day with 3 villager deaths if I picked wrong.

[Emperor Demonking]

So the main things are.

1. More players
2. Make Roy weaker

[Shadowcaller]

And make roles like V a bit stronger, some of the roles are a bit weak compared to others.

[Emperor Demonking]

Sctually I'd say V is the second strongest role not counting Roy.

If V watches someone who's killed you get a villian, you can proove people as liars and get a villian. Though V is weak for team evil he's very good on team good.

[Emperor Demonking]

How many more players? I'm planning. I want to run two of all the small games.