Dethy IV: Logic's Revenge!

[Freshmeat]

A small werewolf game from the mind of Emperor Demonking.

Previous games:

Dethy I
Dethy II
Dethy III

The game consists of five players, one of whom is a mafia member.
There are four scriers on the villager's side. They aren't told who they are.

• The good cop: he gets correct scry results
• The insane cop: he gets opposite scry results
  
  Spoiler

  Show

  The good cop scries as mafia to him.
  The naive cop scries as paranoid to him.
  The paranoid cop scries as naive to him.
  The mafia scries as insane to him.
• The naive cop: he gets random innocent scry results
• The paranoid cop: he always gets a 'mafia' scry result

Their goal is obviously to find and lynch the mafia member.

Additional notes:

• The game starts with a night phase during which the mafia can not yet kill.
• The mafia wins by eluding capture for two days, but he can kill people in the meantime, if he so desires.
• Roles are not revealed upon death.

[Shadowcaller]

I guess I will sign up for this, got my own "mini-wolf" game coming anyway so why not?

[Griever]

Sign me up!

[Dr. Bath]

Dethydethydethydethydethy!!

Yes please.

[detrevnisisiht]

yes .

[Emperor Demonking]

Free wi-fi connection, in.

[Emperor Demonking]

All go for Dr. Bath

Dr. Bath scry me.

[Freshmeat]

And we're off. Role PM's have been sent out to everyone.

Just to remind everyone: the game starts with a night phase.
All of you, with the exception of the mafia of course, can scry someone tonight.

Night 0 ends in 24 hours.

[Emperor Demonking]

All go for Dr. Bath

Dr. Bath scry me.

Want to confirm this.

[detrevnisisiht]

Want to confirm this.

I'm am left confused to your overall plan.

[Emperor Demonking]

If we all scry Dr. bath, we can get confirmed innocents.

[Freshmeat]

Game starts

Scry results will be PM'd shortly.

[Emperor Demonking]

I'm sending Det my result.

Everyone else should send their result to me. This stops wolves from claiming by seeing what everyone else has claimed.

[Griever]

Would rather it all be in the open, personally, as we don't know if we can trust you, EDK.

I scried EDK as mafia.

[Shadowcaller]

I scried EDK as insane.

[Dr. Bath]

Since I got Mafia for EDK that means:

a)I'm the cop, greiver is paranoid EDK is mafia
b)I'm paranoid, greiver is insane and EDK is the cop
c)I'm insane, griever is paranoid and EDK is still the cop
d) Greiver is lying (the mafia) and I'm either insane (EDK is cop) or paranoid (EDK is one of the cops)
e) (it's not d) I'm lying etc. etc.

If the others bring their scries out in the open we could even get the mafia on the first day.

In terms of suspicion, both Griever and EDK are high. EDK for trying to keep all the scries secret (not a good plan) and Greiver for not going along with the plan (which other than keeping the results hidden was a good one).

At this moment in time, Griever is slightly more suspicious in my mind.



C'mon people! Tell your scries! Otherwise it's just EDK playing.

EDIT: Or that works too.

I'm cop (or paranoid)
Shadowcaller is insane
Griever is paranoid (or cop)
detrevnisisiht is naive
EDK is mafia

Emperor Demonking is the mafia

[Griever]

a)I'm the cop, greiver is paranoid EDK is mafia
b)I'm paranoid, greiver is insane and EDK is the cop
c)I'm insane, griever is paranoid and EDK is still the cop
d) Greiver is lying (the mafia) and I'm either insane (EDK is cop) or paranoid (EDK is one of the cops)
e) (it's not d) I'm lying etc. etc.

Wait, so I can't be the cop? *cries*

[Dr. Bath]

It doesn't matter. It comes out the same either way.

[Emperor Demonking]

Would rather it all be in the open, personally, as we don't know if we can trust you, EDK.

I scried EDK as mafia.

If I lied. I would be revealed as a werewolf!!!

Basth scries as insane.

Det scried as insane.

Bath: You think allowing the wolf to see what others chose is a good plasn for town.

EDK
Shadowcaller: Insane
Griever: Mafia
Bath: Mafia
Det: Insanre

Bath: Insane

Bath is mafia

I'm insane or Naive.
Det and Shadowcaller are Naive or sane
Griever: Paranoid

I'm insane, Griever paranoid, Det Naive or sane, Shadowcaller is Naive or Sane

Det is mafia

Griever or Bath are insane or Naive.
I'm Sane.
Shadowcaller is ???

Det is protown

Shadowcaller is mafia
Griever or Bath are insane or Naive.
I'm Sane.
Det is ???

Shadowcaller is pro-town

Greiver is mafia

I'm insane or Naive.
Det and Shadowcaller are Naive or sane
Bath: Paranoid

I'm insane, Griever paranoid, Det Naive or sane, Shadowcaller is Naive or Sane

I'm mafia
Griever and Dr.bath are sane/paranoid.
Shadowcaller and Det are naive/insane.

Dr. Bath

[Dr. Bath]

No, I think that hiding it, and the wolf being the only one with all the information is a bad idea.

You still haven't said who did the scrying. Without that it is far more difficult to work out what doesn't fit.

[Emperor Demonking]

Everyone sends them to me after I send mine away.

I then post them altogrether.

We can all scry.

[detrevnisisiht]

Actualy, The mafia can't.

[Emperor Demonking]

Oh yeah.

So did Dr. Bath want me to reveal the mafia?

[detrevnisisiht]

well, while we are just sitting here....

[Emperor Demonking]

If I'm not mafia. I'm insane.

From my pointn of view:
Griever or Dr. Bath are paranoid.

From your point of view:
Griever and dr. bath can be sane or paranoid.

[Shadowcaller]

If your insane as you claim, I'm the "normal" cop.

[Emperor Demonking]

No you could be naive or sane. Det got the same as you.

I made a mistake.

Griever is mafia

I'm Naive or sane
Shadowcaller is Naive
Det is ???

Only dr. bath or myself can be wolves.

[Griever]

I scried EDK as mafia.
Bath scried EDK as mafia.
Shadowcaller scried EDK as insane.
EDK scried Bath as ______?
Det scried EDK as insane.

Would like clear, written out answers to these so I know I'm not making a stupid assumption or reading incorrectly.

[detrevnisisiht]

I scryed EDK as insane

[Emperor Demonking]

It doesn't matter only me and Dr. Bath can be mafia.

I scried Dr. Bath as insane.

Who instigated the scry EDK stratergy.