Okay, just spitballing here,

It seems to me like Alejandro and Julian are the highest ranking kindred here, but with them having a problem with each other right now, it doesn't seem likely that either will be able to effectively take charge. Correct? Would the group in general at least take instruction from Karl in such a situation?

From there, I am guessing that we do not have a professional Fixer/Cleaner on hand. If so that probably makes Karl the closest thing the group has to an expert at this. His focus is usually on trying to uncover the truth rather than cover it up, but he would still rather intimately familiar with what methods do and do not usually work in regards to keeping police/detectives off of the right trail.

With that in mind, Int+Investigation roll to consider such possibilities? (9d10)[5][3][5][4][6][10][1][5][8](47)