Quote Originally Posted by JoeJ View Post
I didn't say that all X are Y, but that X in the current edition are Y.
Solars occur in several editions of D&D, and all editions of D&D are relevant in this forum. If you a discussion which is limited to 5e Solars, you'd want to visit threads in the 5e subforum, which is not where we are.

5e Solars are always LG.
3e Solars are any good.

Are all Solars LG? No, because not all Solars are 5e Solars.

This really shouldn't be new information for anyone.


Quote Originally Posted by JoeJ View Post
Your jokes were funny. But your response to noob to "please look this stuff up" seemed pretty harsh, considering that noob might well be unfamiliar with editions prior to 5e and very possibly did look that stuff up. Couldn't you have just explained that in 3.x solars can be of any good alignment?
Probably because I saw that post as an attempt to derail the funny into exactly this sort of crappy downward spiral of corrections and defenses. One which you've been instrumental in digging, and which really isn't much fun for me.

It sounds like you're doing this because you're offended on someone else's behalf. Is that accurate?