Witches & Warlocks III: Welcome to Witchtopia! [Game on!]

[Dirk Kris]

Rakkoon - sorry I changed before and got Nome-y killed.

[Lex-Kat]

Looks at all the choices. Decides Eaglewiz is the best choice, for now.

[evnafets]

evnafets points at Inavegt

[Fortuna]

Dirk Kris. Because my brain is tired and I have no better plans.

[rakkoon]

Eaglewiz is good enough for me

[billtodamax]

Dirk Kris for the alternate bandwagon start.

[Zar Peter]

Eagle Wiz to give this bandwagon a little push

[happyturtle]

InaVegt.....

[Aemoh]

*points at InaVegt*

For the tie. Woulda voted for Dirk, but I already tied up vote using him in another game so...

[EagleWiz]

InaVegt because she isnt me

[Sir Stixalot]

As you approach the gathering crowd you hear Sir Stixalot rambling on again. Something about the conviction in his voice makes you stop and listen, or maybe you heard your name mentioned and fear starts to grab you. Either way this is what you hear.....

Nothing like two near witch lynchings to bring the witches out to the forefront!

Here is some analysis, likely to get me night killed. Usually anyone that tries to analyse gets killed. HINT... BANE ME...HINT

Ok, on to buisiness: Who died...

Day 1. Murska: This was the result of actions in a previous life and you should all be lynched for using that as a reason. I considered dropping out when I saw this happen. Toss out the Murska votes as corrupt and we would have lynched Bishfish.

Voted for Bishfish: Lex-Kat, Zar Peter, Robert Blackletter, and rakkoon

Night kill: Kyouhen. Person Kyouhen voted against: Zar Peter

Day 2. Bishfish: At some point Robert Blackletter was tied for lynching. Look at the resulting scramble as he and Inavegt switch their votes to Bishfish and Teh Sheen and Fleeing Coward join in.

Voted for Bishfish: Lex-Kat, rakkoon, InaVegt, Robert Blackletter, Teh Sheen, and Fleeing Coward

Day 3. Sanity702: rakoon and Sanity702 tie up for lynching. Here we have an interesting group of ten single points and 2 band wagons. One at least seems run by villagers who almost work together and lynch rakkoon. Resulting witch scramble... Sanity702 dies.

Voted for Sanity702: Robert Blackletter, Teh Sheen, Fleeing Coward, rakkoon, and Lex-Kat who suspiciously steps out and billtodamax steps in.

Day 4 so far. EagleWiz: or InaVegt. Since no one on the InaVegt wagon has lynched a single villager or nuetral yet, I don't suspect them. But look who is pushing the other wagon:

Voting for EagleWiz: Lex-Kat, rakkoon, Zar Peter

Lets cover who the targeted people voted against just to add evidence.

EagleWiz: Voted for InaVegt today, rakkoon day 3, and Zar Peter day 2

Sanity702: On the day he died, voted for rakkoon to save his own hide, but originally was pointing at Robert Blackletter.

Bishfish: On the day he died, voted for InaVegt.

Let me sum up who should be lynched and why:

Top 3 (The save Robert Blackletter team):
1. Robert Blackletter. On all 3 wagons (yes I consider the push for BishFish day 1 the REAL wagon). Amazingly saved from lynching by 4 people, making those 4 my top suspects. Lynch him last of the top 5 to give me 5 days more to live please, because with the effort they mustered I wouldn't be suprised if he is the Wicked Witch of the East. (did I mention to Bane me yet?)

2. Teh Sheen. On the two bandwagons that saved Robert Blackletter and rakkoon. Votes immediately following Robert Blackletter, saving him.

3. Fleeing Coward. Also on the two witch saving bandwagons. Also rushed to aid Robert Blackletter when he was in danger.



The Terrible Two:
4. rakkoon. On all 3 wagons as well as the new one for day 4. Also survived a lynch, due to 4 of the same people that saved Robert Blackletter. I admit his simple pleas of innocence are tempting, DON"T believe them.

5. InaVeg. One wagon, but switched to Bishfish, switching votes is suspect, especially when it helps save the number one Witch.

The Unusual Suspects:
6. Lex-Kat. On every single bandwagon. Except the last minute switch away from Sanity702. No worries, billtodamax took the spot.

7. Zar Peter. One wagon, and day 4 wagon. Switched his vote off of Robert Blackletter twice, once only minutes after making it. Wolves pretending to point at wolves in my opinion. Was the target of the only person night killed so far.

8. billtodamax. Such a low profile, last on the list because the swapout between billtodamax and Lex-Kat again seems like wolves pointing at wolves, especially since the next day they don't try to accuse each other at all. Most importantly, without his help, rakkoon would have been lynched.

So, there it is. Kill these 8 and the village should win. If I get some villagers killed by mistake, sorry, but you shouldn't have been acting so suspicious. Plus, you have been killing villagers! You should be ashamed of yourselves. The Witches may pick whoever is on this list that isn't a witch and try to kill them first to prove me wrong. I admit that some of the 8 might be village, but taken as a group, there is high likelyhood you will finish off all of the witches.

As for my vote, I'll point with the InaVegt group since the ball is already rolling, even though he isn't as certain as my top three are.

Sir Stixalot

[rakkoon]

you shouldn't have been acting so suspicious.

I seem to do that a lot
If I start a bandwagon, I'm suspicious
If I follow a bandwagon, I'm suspicious
If I'm innocent in 99.9% of the games, I'm suspicious

I get why I never get to be a wolf

[Deathslayer7]

only 11 votes in? come on people.

[Robert Blackletter]

rant... kill robert... kill rakkoon kill everyone but me.... rant

While he is not entirly without logic, think about it, the last two night there has been no night kill, I have been very active in the thread. would any wolf team allow two night running without kills? one could be bad luck with baner two seems strange. With me being active i would say it unlikely that if i was a wolf that would happen.

Secondly i have contacted a rakkoon and two others and made deals not to kill each other. While this dose not clear me it dose explain strange voting patterns around me. i have basically passed the buck on to nearest easy target each time me or a "partner" been in the firing line.

I must say yopu asking to be baned is strange as killing you would surely put credence to what you say? you surely safer then anyone else now as killing you would make village look at the list closely while not killing you may divert attention away from you. Anyway if there a seer please check me out in the night phase and let stixalot that he being a fool. (after checking him outm of course, it could be a double bluff)

Now i pointing InaVegt to join band wagon.


Edit also feel I should justify my points/ actions so here go's

Day one was semi-random as felt that Murska should not be punish for what happen in last game and that he was a resource as highly unlikely to be wolf. discussed this in thread.
day two well I got unfairly bandwagon for merely saying I will follow someone logic if they point some out. I pointed at whatever target seem likely to overcome mine. That some thought that was not a good reason to kill some one is not surprising.
day 3. I voted at sanity first and it was also as a counter point. i have admitted i have an agreement with rakkoon so was not going to put an ally in danger for no reason so no need to change off of him.
day 4.. only just voted and following lead bandwagon.
hope that clears it up.

[Deathslayer7]

I only have 2/3 of the votes in.

<----- not happy face.

[Fleeing Coward]

Eaglewiz since I don't think I've voted.

[Shadowcaller]

Ealgewiz for now.

[cd4]

I think I will join with the logic wagon rather than the counterwagon with no logic. InaVegt.

Currently however this will tie the votes.

[rakkoon]

Let's change that then InaVegt

Now I do have a problem with that list.
I'm a boring villager.
Bill is suspect for saving me (a villager).
I did not vote for Robert first because we've double crossed each other seven times already and then because he asked. Teh Sheen saved me and Robert, i'm not a wolf so that proves nothing. I have no poblem with lynching everyone on that list since I also do not know whether Robert is a wolf or not but a lot of your reasoning is intertwined.

We can lynch Inavegt and Fleeing Coward perhaps? If those two are not wolves then your reasoning stinks?

I appreciate someone doing an analysis and you might be right about some but the card house kind of falls apart if ... ah well, let's lynch those two and see.

[Fleeing Coward]

Sir Stixalot's whole analysis seems to be based on the fact that he believes Robert is a witch yet he asks us to lynch everyone but Robert. Anyone else find this a little unusual?

To the baner, unless you are 100% certain that Sir Stixalot isn't a wolf and that you're safe, you bane yourself, plain and simple. Sir Stixalot hasn't claimed a role yet and he's basically cast suspicion on half the player base.
If you want to see what that does if a wolf is behind it, check out AC II and Fears

[Lex-Kat]

Just a small defense of my actions.

Day 1: Yeah, I joined the 2nd bandwagon against Bishfish, in the hopes of saving Murska.

And guess what, Murska was a Munchkin. Sue me.

Day 2: I was the first to point at BishFish. Call it retaliation for him not dying instead of Murska. But I didn't call on anyone to follow.

Yet, follow me they did.

Day 3: The Sanity702/Rakkoon affair. I explained why I changed my vote already.

The reason I pointed at Sanity in the first place, was because everyone was pointing at someone who hadn't been pointed at yet. He was first in the conga line, so I pointed at him.

Why didn't I point at Rakkoon? Because for some reason, Rakkoon said this:

Ow man, I can't vote for TPAM... Dirk kris?

And that made me curious as to why.

Now that I've had time to think about it, he very well could be a wolf, trying to cast suspicion on me with his poor choice of words.

[Sir Stixalot]

Rules given out at the beginning.

Deathslayer7:

There are no masons in this game!
Helgraf's Scry interference rule is in effect!
And no public role-claiming!

So, in response to:

Fleeing Coward:

Sir Stixalot hasn't claimed a role yet and he's basically cast suspicion on half the player base.

If I could claim a role I would, but we arn't allowed to, which cripples the village in my opinion.

I already admitted my list could have issues. All I did was list out who has been killing villagers. Strangly enough it is the same people over and over. The witches know who each other are and can work together to create bandwagons, while for 4 days the village has pretty much been silent and spreding their votes out, ten different directions at one point. Some of you could be caught in the middle, accidently helping out the witches admittedly.

I am convinced Robert Blackletter is a witch, and probably the Wicked Witch of the East. That means if you kill him next, he will take someone with him when he dies, probably me unless the baner chooses not to bane me and they can kill me tonight.

Fleeing Coward and Teh Sheen helped save him from lynching as well as beeing part of villager bandwagons. Fleeing Coward and Robert Blacklettter are also trying to convince you I am a witch so you will lynch me. A villager will see that my list stands for itself, even though it is not and can not be perfect. Several of the accused are making very valid points to try and save themselves and may deserve a scry from someone to double check. Others are trying to discredit my simple list of who dies and who killed them. Stating facts should not make you think I am a witch. Trying to kill me for stating facts, should make you wonder about those accusing me.

That being said, I am not at all sure InaVegt is a witch, but trying to switch everyones votes to one of my top three this late in the day would probably just scatter peoples votes and kill Eaglewiz for sure, whom I do not suspect at all. Lynch Fleeing Coward, Lynch Teh Sheen, and Lynch Robert Blackletter. At that point, if I am wrong and still alive, Lynch me for being an idiot.

Several people need a scry, thats for sure. I wonder who could possibly give them one?

Sir Stixalot

[Fleeing Coward]

If you're certain Robert Blackletter is who you say he is, we lynch him, plain and simple. I've always assumed the beast can only kill someone that voted for them but Deathslayer7 can correct me if this isn't the case in this game.

Also, I highly doubt you are the one that can give people their scries because only a foolish seer would accuse someone else without the use of a proxy after 3 days.

[Robert Blackletter]

I'm trying to get you kill Stixalot? How?
I merely pointed out that killing you is counter productive for the wolves. If your wrong (and in my case you are) and they kill you people look closer kill one maybe two more (prob me but here hoping not) then ignore your list. lowering suspect elsewhere and providing a solid group to focus around to kill non-members of your list. If your right in part then if you start killing your list those not on it kill those off of it and then whittle down number leading to a likely wolves victory. (8 people on list, let say two wolves on list that means roughly 14 innocent killed (including night kills assuming they are active again after holidays ) if everyone concentrates on it. If your completely right then it leads to villager victory but that is unlikely.
Again any seer here please check me out and let young stix know the truth

[TehSheen]

Adding some logic to my points, I was just following the bandwagons because I haven't been paying much attention to the thread. Also, evening the two bandwagons with a point at Eaglewiz.

[Deathslayer7]

ok. day ends.

Stix: yay! someone listened to the rules! I'm happy!

FC: that is correct. Only people who vote for the wicked witch of the east can by killed by her ability, at the witche's choice of course. Day banes or don't cover this.

[Deathslayer7]

All fluff is just that: fluff.

Taxes! Taxes! I'm here to collect the taxes! a lone voice rang out over the crowd, many with cross looks on their faces.

We don't have to pay taxes anymore! one of the munchkins shouted out. We don't belong to the witch!

The tax collector shouted back. If you don't pay your taxes! The Wicked Witch - Bless her - will burn your houses to the ground in a fiery rain of death! A cry of fear went through the crowd, and slowly they lined up. The tax collector went through them, one by one, making sure they paid their taxes. He reached Oddity and Opeth_Freak who had trouble scrounging up the money. Friends helped them out. When he reached Inavegt, she wasn't as lucky. She couldn't collect the money. They dragged her away to the dungeon.

Summary:

Spoiler

Show

Inavegt was lynched. She was a Munchkin.
Oddity and Opeth_freak must vote tomorrow or be autolynched.

Night 4 Begins and ends in 24 hours! Get your night actions in to The Bookworm and I.

[Fleeing Coward]

FC: that is correct. Only people who vote for the wicked witch of the east can by killed by her ability, at the witche's choice of course. Day banes or don't cover this.

Well, this makes it easy then. If you're confident enough in your accusations Sir Stixalot, I'm prepared to lynch Robert tomorrow. You can point elsewhere if you want.
If Robert doesn't turn out to be a witch though, you're next on the chopping block.

[rakkoon]

Lex-cat,
First I said

Bishfish because Lex-cat is always right

Then I didn't vote for you because you have been right a couple of times.
This is a clever plan of me to get you killed because I'm a wolf?
No comprendo.

But nevermind, kill/scry Robert, if innocent, kill/scry Stixalot. I like that plan.

Oh and Robert, if you're a wolf, I'm gonna get you killed in the next 27 games we play together!!! If not, sorry.

[Zar Peter]

...
Oh and Robert, if you're a wolf, I'm gonna get you killed in the next 27 games we play together!!! If not, sorry.

I second that statement but I make it 26 games since I already killed him in one

On the other hand this is a game about lying... I think I just observe him better in other games.