Quote Originally Posted by Menteith View Post
Kelb_Panthera, after considering it, you are correct. By RAW, Book of Vile Darkness is a primary source with regard to alignment, and I'm not going to find an argument that will change that. With that said, I would still urge individuals to handle alignment issues more carefully than the strict RAW. Good discussion, KP.
Thank you, Menteith, for one of the most entertaining discussions I've had on this forum to date.

To anyone else who's enjoyed this debate, I agree with Menteith's statement that if you're going to take alignment any kind of seriously in your game, you should have a discussion with your group about how it will be handled. The RAW is pretty controversial, as we've amply demonstrated by now.

Have a nice day.