Witchunt V1.0 (WW Variant)

[Milskidasith]

I'd play again, just to see the other four roles.

I'd also appreciate the "majority ends the day" being adjusted, maybe raised to 70% or something.

Majority ends the day is not going to be changed, especially not to make it so that it is requires unanimous town+JW+WW in order to actually get anywhere. Just use preview post and count the votes.

[lostlittlebear]

D2: Town lynches priest, who makes multiple posts at lynch-1 and neither he nor the acolyte (who was also posting while the priest was getting pretty heavily voted) defend themselves.

Well yeah, I was waiting for Mordokai to defend himself so I could give him support. I didn't expect he'd give up completely without a fight . I tried to set up FC as an alternate lynch target but as afraid of being too forward in my defense w/o Mordokai posting first because I was afraid of revealing our acolyte/priest connection. After Mordokai was lynched, the only thing I really could do to help the game onwards was reveal myself and hope that the wolves were feelig confident enough to sacrifice one of their own to get at the priest (who was pretty much the only hope the town had of winning had they remained silent). I'm glad it worked, but I agree it was pretty bad play because it was seriously a longshot.

As for EDs claim, well I believed it because I suspected Murska was the JW since I didn't see people jumping to his support like I assumed the coven would, and also because I felt the wolves would have doe a better job if they planned it together and faked it.

Few questions:
Could we see witch/GA chat? It might be interesting to look at their discussions
Is there a version of witchhunt with PMing?
Will you run this again? I have a feeling I might play better the next time now that i have a proper grasp of how the rules work.

[Ghanz Nmi]

Well yeah, I was waiting for Mordokai to defend himself so I could give him support. I didn't expect he'd give up completely without a fight . I tried to set up FC as an alternate lynch target but as afraid of being too forward in my defense w/o Mordokai posting first because I was afraid of revealing our acolyte/priest connection. After Mordokai was lynched, the only thing I really could do to help the game onwards was reveal myself and hope that the wolves were feelig confident enough to sacrifice one of their own to get at the priest (who was pretty much the only hope the town had of winning had they remained silent). I'm glad it worked, but I agree it was pretty bad play because it was seriously a longshot.

As for EDs claim, well I believed it because I suspected Murska was the JW since I didn't see people jumping to his support like I assumed the coven would, and also because I felt the wolves would have doe a better job if they planned it together and faked it.

Few questions:
Could we see witch/GA chat? It might be interesting to look at their discussions
Is there a version of witchhunt with PMing?
Will you run this again? I have a feeling I might play better the next time now that i have a proper grasp of how the rules work.

I too would like to see Witchchat. You don't want to see GAchat, though, it's... Nothing to be proud of.

[Milskidasith]

Chats:

GA

Witch Chat 1
Witch chat 2

Lover Chat (Note: Not much went on here).

I will probably run another one, but it will most likely still be a 17 person game. I don't feel like waiting a couple months in order to make a game.

[Internet Flea]

Have you asked Thufir about it? I think they might let a 21-player game slide.

And you left out the final witchchat! The one where the only comment was how pointless the final witchchat was!

[Milskidasith]

Have you asked Thufir about it? I think they might let a 21-player game slide.

And you left out the final witchchat! The one where the only comment was how pointless the final witchchat was!

I made that one just to facepalm the entire situation, actually.

[Sotek]

Oh man those were some great reads.

... I am so boned next game here, unless I get nun and you're using this version of nun. oh well~

[Istari]

Main thing I notice is that ED's spy claim was mostly bought a credible in GA chat, and everyone thought I was a witch

[Murska]

It was a bit of a problem that both of the people who had previous experience with this type of game and were vocal (Fry in WitchChat at least, vocal-ish) happened to be the Werewolf and the Spy and working secretly for their own agenda. Us poor total newbies got a bit confused.

[Milskidasith]

It was a bit of a problem that both of the people who had previous experience with this type of game and were vocal (Fry in WitchChat at least, vocal-ish) happened to be the Werewolf and the Spy and working secretly for their own agenda. Us poor total newbies got a bit confused.

Well Dragon Child was also experienced and got VH and died. It was all completely random.

[Ghanz Nmi]

Main thing I notice is that ED's spy claim was mostly bought a credible in GA chat, and everyone thought I was a witch

You weren't exactly making much of a case for yourself, to be fair.

To the GAs it didn't matter too much if his claim was right or not, though, since each person knew pretty much knew who they wanted to bane for most of the rest of the game.

Oh, and Milski, save me a spot when you make another!

[CitizenFry]

For the record, I believed LLB's Aco-claim, but "priest claiming Aco" is a reasonable play for someone to make, and it was the only thing that could save me from a sacrifice at that point, so I went for it.

[Mannikath]

Hi, I followed this game and it looks every interesting. I was going to sign up for another game, but if this is being hosted again I would be interested in playing. Will people who did not play the first time be eligible to join?

[Ghanz Nmi]

For the record, I believed LLB's Aco-claim, but "priest claiming Aco" is a reasonable play for someone to make, and it was the only thing that could save me from a sacrifice at that point, so I went for it.

Right, forgot you were Spy!Demon, and probably have your coven baying for your blood considering your hilarious fake scries.