Witchunt V1.0 Game 2 (WW Variant)

[Internet Flea]

My quote was supposed to be half a joke!
and then Recaiden didn't really respond like that, raising my suspicions.

But um if he's a witch, lynching him is good.

I know, but I saw the quote and missed the source.
Also, the "smilie" means I'm joking too.


See? Doesn't that just scream "humor"?

[Ghanz Nmi]

I know, but I saw the quote and missed the source.
Also, the "smilie" means I'm joking too.


See? Doesn't that just scream "humor"?

The one in your bone?

[Sotek]

OKAY THEN!

May as well repost the vote tally for a new page.

-------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! Please remember to specify your votes in red.
21 people alive, so 11 is a majority, and 11 is a deadlock.
{table=head]Player|Votes|Voting
Sotek|3|bruntonspall, Murksa, Recaiden
Aemoh|4|Horoar, Istari, Hitaro, Orzel
Hitaro|8|Gray Mage, Sotek, SHAZAM, metlink, Tydude, Duneyrr, Eternal Drifter, Wheat LYNCH MINUS THREE!
Orzel|1|Aemoh
Gray Mage|2|Mannicath, Internet Flea
[/table]
-------------------------

Want to hear things from people in general, though.

[metlink]

I finally have time to squeeze a post with sentences today! Yay! I am going to be in and out of the computer until about 6PM AST. I am fixing lighting fixtures around the home and it's not easy. Anyway, WH:

I see almost two pages of posts, half being about spelling errors and polls. All of my objections have been mentioned and clarified by either Ghanz, Sotek
or Recaiden.

[hr]
However, I do want to hear more from SHAZAM until Hitaro comes back to defend himself. Their voting pattern of randavoting-switching without explanation and then making a nonsensical post without contributing much in forms of words, rubs me the wrong way.

Finally, I want to hear more from bruntonspall, Mannikath as well. My reads on them are inconclusive and I want their opinions on the current state of affairs.

[hr]
I also hope VA_Beds comes back, though I am sure there is a good reason why!

[Hitaro]

****it, I'm the traveller. You guys are huge jerks

[Ghanz Nmi]

I finally have time to squeeze a post with sentences today! Yay! I am going to be in and out of the computer until about 6PM AST. I am fixing lighting fixtures around the home and it's not easy. Anyway, WH:

I see almost two pages of posts, half being about spelling errors and polls. All of my objections have been mentioned and clarified by either Ghanz, Sotek
or Recaiden.

<hr>
However, I do want to hear more from SHAZAM until Hitaro comes back to defend himself. Their voting pattern of randavoting-switching without explanation and then making a nonsensical post without contributing much in forms of words, rubs me the wrong way.

Finally, I want to hear more from bruntonspall, Mannikath as well. My reads on them are inconclusive and I want their opinions on the current state of affairs.

<hr>
I also hope VA_Beds comes back, though I am sure there is a good reason why!

Also rakkoon, who hasn't said a word yet so far.

[Ghanz Nmi]

****it, I'm the traveller. You guys are huge jerks

You couldn't have claimed Priest or something so the Witches would waste a NK or two on you? We would never lynch a Day 1 Priest-claim.

Well, what does everyone think about this Traveller claim?

[Gray Mage]

You couldn't have claimed Priest or something so the Witches would waste a NK or two on you? We would never lynch a Day 1 Priest-claim.

Well, what does everyone think about this Traveller claim?

It's possible. Could be a fake claim to avoid NK, but I wouldn't bet on it. So now we change targets or what?

[Internet Flea]

Well, what does everyone think about this Traveller claim?

I think that if he's lying the real one has little to gain by not counterclaiming.

[Internet Flea]

Unless he's a powerful role pretending to be the traveller, in which case I guess it might hurt us pretty bad.

Never mind.

[Sotek]

You couldn't have claimed Priest or something so the Witches would waste a NK or two on you? We would never lynch a Day 1 Priest-claim.

Well, what does everyone think about this Traveller claim?

Man, I really do not like it at all.

at *all*. He couldn't've at least tried to fight against claiming a little bit? Feels so suspicious to me.

[Ghanz Nmi]

It's possible. Could be a fake claim to avoid NK, but I wouldn't bet on it. So now we change targets or what?

I did not consider that possibility. That is true.

I think that if he's lying the real one has little to gain by not counterclaiming.

Well, the real Traveller probably would not want to counterclaim if that was indeed a fakeclaim, because a known Traveller is useless to us, since the Witches will just not target him, except on a sac night. It also increases the probability of the Witches hitting an actually vulnerable role if Traveller is known, so yeah, real Traveller should not counterclaim if he is indeed out there.

Either way, I'll put a point on Gray Mage as the next person to pressure today. Sotek is being pretty town, and Aemoh has done nothing to make me suspicious of him. Gray Mage is also around pretty often, so we could get another role sorted out in the first Day.

[Ghanz Nmi]

Man, I really do not like it at all.

at *all*. He couldn't've at least tried to fight against claiming a little bit? Feels so suspicious to me.

Well, why claim Traveller of all roles? It doesn't really do much to dissuade people from lynching you anyway, since a known Traveller is a pretty useless role...

On the other hand, he could be a Witch trying to explain why he is never targeted, but his cover is blown the moment the Witches have a sac night, so I think we can afford to wait a bit. And if he is any power role/WW trying to hide behind the possibility of being Traveller, he just painted a target on his head during the first sac night.

I'm switching to a new target because I believe that's all we're going to get out of Hitaro for now.

[Gray Mage]

Changing points from Hitaro to Aemoh. To put some pressure on him, based on the fact that he isn't me.
Anyway, I already know some for me to keep an eye on.

[Sotek]

Well, why claim Traveller of all roles? It doesn't really do much to dissuade people from lynching you anyway, since a known Traveller is a pretty useless role...

Hmm. Yeah, I guess. I'm not hugely happy with it still, but we can wait a while for him to get revealed.

I'm switching to a new target because I believe that's all we're going to get out of Hitaro for now.

Ugh. Reasonable. I'm inclined to say our next target should be Aemoh, then.

-------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! Please remember to specify your votes in red.
21 people alive, so 11 is a majority, and 11 is a deadlock.
{table=head]Player|Votes|Voting
Sotek|3|bruntonspall, Murksa, Recaiden
Aemoh|6|Horoar, Istari, Hitaro, Orzel, Gray Mage, Sotek
Hitaro|7|Sotek, SHAZAM, metlink, Tydude, Duneyrr, Eternal Drifter, Wheat
Orzel|1|Aemoh
Gray Mage|3|Mannicath, Internet Flea, Ghanz Nmi
[/table]
-------------------------

[Ghanz Nmi]

Sigh, no one else thinks Gray Mage is suspicious?

I'll switch from Gray Mage to Aemoh, then. Let's get someone talking, at least.

[Sotek]

He really doesn't seem suspicious to me, no.

He does seem active, but man, consider the power of an ACTIVE GUY VOTING BLOCK!

-------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! Please remember to specify your votes in red.
21 people alive, so 11 is a majority, and 11 is a deadlock.
{table=head]Player|Votes|Voting
Sotek|3|bruntonspall, Murksa, Recaiden
Aemoh|7|Horoar, Istari, Hitaro, Orzel, Gray Mage, Sotek, Ghanz Nmi
Hitaro|7|Sotek, SHAZAM, metlink, Tydude, Duneyrr, Eternal Drifter, Wheat
Orzel|1|Aemoh
Gray Mage|2|Mannicath, Internet Flea
[/table]
-------------------------

[Gray Mage]

He really doesn't seem suspicious to me, no.

He does seem active, but man, consider the power of an ACTIVE GUY VOTING BLOCK!

You forgot to erase your vote for Hitaro, Sotek.

[Murska]

Fine. Aemoh, to break the tie. HA.

[Sotek]

Whoops, table error.
-------------------------
Post reference link
Sotek's unofficial vote tally! Please remember to specify your votes in red.
21 people alive, so 11 is a majority, and 11 is a deadlock.
{table=head]Player|Votes|Voting
Sotek|2|bruntonspall, Recaiden
Aemoh|8|Horoar, Istari, Hitaro, Orzel, Gray Mage, Sotek, Ghanz Nmi, Murska
Hitaro|6|SHAZAM, metlink, Tydude, Duneyrr, Eternal Drifter, Wheat
Orzel|1|Aemoh
Gray Mage|2|Mannicath, Internet Flea
[/table]
-------------------------

[Gray Mage]

Aemoh is also at lynch-3, right? Should be carefull to vote for him now.

[Ghanz Nmi]

Aemoh sitting at Lynch -3, don't put too many votes on him now, people, or we will lynch your butt tomorrow!

[Sotek]

Oh hey, that's LYNCH MINUS THREE! for Aemoh. Time for words to start falling out, sir.

[Internet Flea]

I'm going to suggest we limit roleclaims to around two a day so the Werewolf doesn't become all-powerful all of the sudden.

[Tydude]

And I just got home! Personally, I don't find Aemoh that suspicious. He's doing what he always does. On Hitaro, I think he actually is the Traveler or he's a more powerful role trying to not get NK. Either way, I don't think he's scum. I'll keep my vote on him though so he doesn't fall completely off the radar.

[Gray Mage]

I'm going to suggest we limit roleclaims to around two a day so the Werewolf doesn't become all-powerful all of the sudden.

So we should let two role-claim, and then kill one of the two? Or a third person? Also, not every claim will be true.

[Ghanz Nmi]

I'm going to suggest we limit roleclaims to around two a day so the Werewolf doesn't become all-powerful all of the sudden.

We probably won't be able to move fast enough anyway, but remember that anyone can lie about their roles, and so long as our Spy is alive, the WW cannot win the game even if he knows the role of every person.

[Ghanz Nmi]

So we should let two role-claim, and then kill one of the two? Or a third person? Also, not every claim will be true.

I say we keep pushing until someone's claim really doesn't sit well with us, then we kill them. Day lynch gives the person's identity to the Medium, so no-lynch is not good Town play Day 1. It's also important to have someone in the GA chat, so we can start with banes immediately. Preferably not a strong Town role, though, we'd like those alive. Since the GAs will actually know who the Priest is, having Town GAs early will keep our Priest alive, too.

[Gray Mage]

Since the GAs will actually know who the Priest is, having Town GAs early will keep our Priest alive, too.

They do? I didn't find this in the GA part in the first post.

[Tydude]

They do? I didn't find this in the GA part in the first post.

Yeah, I didn't know that either last game. The GA's are told who the Priest is and who he checks.