V's Gender Debate IV [Official]

[Mr. Pin]

I don't think it was always like this... I just think that since V has been the focus of the comic lately, the topic of her gender (being the most interesting part of her) has, naturally, surfaced quite a bit. And I haven't noticed any more than one thread every 2 or so weeks...

[MickJay]

You're right, of course, but this only creates extra opportunities to read all the arguments before making a new thread.

Also, why be satisfied with only 50% probability of being right? Make one topic "V is male", one "V is female", throw in a remark that he's really hermaphroditic in someone else's thread, and you can be almost sure you were right somewhere

[danelsan]

{Scrubbed}

[Silverraptor]

{Scrubbed}

{Scrubbed}

[Undead Prince]

{Scrubbed}

Hey dude, I got slapped by the mods for precisely this, can you imagine? 8=))) Deja vu!

So, I dunno, heed my example, or somesuch?

[Nimrod's Son]

{scrubbed}

Why just Pixies? Intelligence and post count have absolutely zero to do with each other; I've seen plenty of very seasoned posters spouting this kind of nonsense before.

Face it, ANYONE who claims they know for a fact what gender V is doesn't know what they're talking about. Full stop.

[Godskook]

So... first I'm gonna make a Fortidude save against imagining any underwearless-ness in this comic...

Actually, its a will save...

[Code Black]

There's only one definite way to find out someone's gender.

Now, as for finding someone fool enough to try...

[CrimsonAngel]

This raises the question of why someone who flies around all the time wears loose, flowing robes. I know it's wizardy and all, but it cant be easy on the eyes for people stuck on the ground.

*gives a cookie to*

[evileeyore]

Thanks Rorscharch, now do you want to tell me something I don't know?

Rorshach's journal, March 22nd, 2009:

Three gang members defaced building across from public library. Posters on messageboard inordinantly interested in sex of comic character, not healthy, sign of decaying social morals like a plague spread mind to mind through the eyes. Unsure best method of curing this ill.

[MickJay]

Not that I'm complaining, but why was a thread discussing the recurrence of threads about V's gender merged with a topic discussing V's gender? I mean, it wasn't the same topic, nobody was even claiming that they know V's gender, it was more of a meta-thread to begin with.

[CapedLuigiYoshi]

There's only one definite way to find out someone's gender.

Now, as for finding someone fool enough to try...

Wouldn't that hurt anyone of either gender?

[Amitabho]

simply kicking V in the lower regions

That would kinda hurt the same for a woman as for a man.

Assuming you're not being sarcastic.

[Estrosiath]

Actually, Belkar already knows V's gender.

All he needs to do is go check out a book on lizard anathomy and he'd be golden.

[V'icternus]

Actually, its a will save...

If we were using 4e rules, I'd just make a death saving throw and save myself some trouble...

[Ziriath]

Belkar doesnt know, that the only visible part of the lizard's body to do with reproduction is horizontally oriented anus, which looks by both genders the same:):P:D

[brionl]

After this latest strip, there can be no more debate. With his attempted weasling out of trouble; "Ventral Planes" "Limited Lease" that's guy talk. No chick would say anything like that.

After Kyrie yelled "YOU SOLD YOUR SOUL!" my first thought was "lease" even before I read V's reply.

[Cúchulainn]

Yeah he's totally whipped.

[enarch3t]

Please, that is utter nonsense. You obviously don't know any female lawyers.

[Shadowbane]

My mother is a lawyer and she talks like that.

[bsparrow]

Eh, I think this is more of a "which thinks more logically" type of thing. There's no doubt that V is very left-brained and logical, whereas Kyrie seems more... well... not. Yeah, Kyrie does seem more feminine in many ways (having a domestic career, staying at home to take care of the kids, etc) but that doesn't necessarily mean anything.

Yeah, I'm in the "V is a guy" camp too... but face it. We're not going to find out, except as maybe a one-off joke at the very end.

Good luck explaining your logic, though.

[Kaytara]

As just mentioned, Kyrie seems to be quite male visually but talks and acts in a very emotional touchy-feely feminine way. So where does that leave us? Typical gender roles obviously don't mean a thing in OotS-land.

[Yana]

I know this idea has likely been presented before, but nevertheless: What if V and Kyrie were both male/female? I seem to recall V saying that his/her children were adopted.

[TheSummoner]

I know this idea has likely been presented before, but nevertheless: What if V and Kyrie were both male/female? I seem to recall V saying that his/her children were adopted.

Possible, but theres no evidence of it so until some magically appears, its safest to go with the default.

Personally, I see Kyrie as very feminine... the behavior, the hair (this coming from a guy with long hair), and even the name all scream female at me.

Of course... its possible Kyrie is just a shortened form of her name used by V (similar to "Suvie")

Kyrannar? Kyreus? Kyrith?

[SlyGuyMcFly]

Of course... its possible Kyrie is just a shortened form of her name used by V (similar to "Suvie")

Kyrannar? Kyreus? Kyrith?[/QUOTE]

Vaarkyrius, obviously

[X2]

I know this idea has likely been presented before, but nevertheless: What if V and Kyrie were both male/female? I seem to recall V saying that his/her children were adopted.

That is my belief... they are both drawn like men so I conclude that they are gay lovers. But who the heck really knows...

BURLEW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ZerglingOne]

Ahem, since Kyrie is the name of my ex-GIRLfriend, I will now always see V as male. Even if Rich honestly stated V as female, I still wouldn't believe Kyrie was male.

[The Rose Dragon]

I like the idea that Kyrie stands for Valkyrie. Kudos to the person that came up with it.

[Iranon]

For me, it'll always be a Greek vocative - 'Oh Lord!'.

Which, as a nickname, makes me imagine him as some very hot stuff!

[Johnny Blade]

Personally, I see Kyrie as very feminine... the behavior, the hair (this coming from a guy with long hair), and even the name all scream female at me.

Judging by what we've seen in the comic, one can safely assume that Elves wouldn't actually see it as feminine, since they apparently don't have any concept of gender at all, so this means nothing.

So, it may seem feminine to you, but you're not an elf. (Probably.)