A Harry Potter Universe W/W Game (Game Started Page 2)

[Blue Ghost]

It's for the greater good. How many wolves here would like to face a 5 person confirmed villager group as well as the masons?

I don't see how this is possible, but if you've managed such an incredible feat, I don't see why we need to tear it down just for the sake of game balance. These are Death Eaters we're dealing with, after all.
If you really don't mind hindering your efforts that, can you tell me how you did this? I'm really curious. Of course, you don't have to if doing so would be too risky.
Oh, and do you still have a way to confirm people? I'm a villager, and I'd love to join your network, if it's possible.

[Fleeing Coward]

Role PM loophole. Started out as just 3 villagers via msn convo but I might have taken things just abit too far by pming a couple of other villagers.

[TehSheen]

Hey, if you just managed such an incredible feat, you can use it to achieve the quickest Team Good win! A huge feat indeed.

[Lex-Kat]

Hey, if you just managed such an incredible feat, you can use it to achieve the quickest Team Good win! A huge feat indeed.

Makes for a REALLY boring game. Not just for those of us who wish to find the wolves, but for the wolves who have no chance of winning.

And the loophole is......

Your an Inncoent (Villager).

Notice the spelling of "Inncoent".

Oh, and lynch Fleeing Coward for balance.

[whitehelm]

If I recall, this happened in a previous game and it got completely ruined for everyone. The villagers decimated the wolves in just a few days and no one had any fun. So it looks like this "seer test" is garbage and we've been following a group of villagers around.

I think there should be a policy that narrators either post the role PMs publicly or custom make the villager PMs, to stop this happening again.

[Lex-Kat]

I suggest posting the Role PMs. It's a lot easier, especially when you get a lot of players.

I also suggest, since the game has just started, maybe MOD could shift the Roles around and start over.

[Fleeing Coward]

Yea, the game's screwed for the wolves because of that loophole since I forgot to take into account the masons in my calculations.

Also, my money's on Lex-Kat as wolf.

[MOD]

At the moment I am currently discussing things. The game shall continue as planned for now.

[Lex-Kat]

Yea, the game's screwed for the wolves because of that loophole since I forgot to take into account the masons in my calculations.

Also, my money's on Lex-Kat as wolf.

Your money would show that you are wrong.

[happyturtle]

As a narrator, I favor either posting all role PMs somewhere in the rules (scrubbed of names), or making it a rule infraction to share them. It's clever, but it's also outside the conditions that narrators try to balance for when they build the game.

[Deathslayer7]

Looking into this, with a 5-confirmed group of villagers parading around as well as mason, wolves don't really stand a chance now do they. All it takes is for a single villager to get into contact with the masons, then you have half the people confirmed as Good. Plus the seer and baner still alive, all you have to do is scry one of these people to get into the network.

From an outside point of view, I would either scrap this game (because of that) or start over.

Now if FC hasn't told anyone yet who the villagers are, thats a different story and might yet still be solveable by either lynching FC and have him keep quiet or just take him out of the game.

[MOD]

After more backroom discussions the game will continue as is until the second day phase is over then some stuff will happen.

[Fleeing Coward]

Can we lynch Lex-Kat then? She got the villager role PM wrong

[rakkoon]

"Alas poor Opeth_Freak, I knew thee not, breakfast is good though"
"What's up with Lex-Kat ? Did someone put a curse on her hair or something?"

[Blue Ghost]

Can we lynch Lex-Kat then? She got the villager role PM wrong

She did indeed. Maybe she got a different role PM, but that would obviate the loophole. But if she was a wolf, she would be exposing herself for no reason. I am very confused.

After more backroom discussions the game will continue as is until the second day phase is over then some stuff will happen.

That... does not sound good.

[rakkoon]

It seems that the Death Eaters will be recruiting agressively ... dark times ahead

[Blue Ghost]

It seems that the Death Eaters will be recruiting agressively ... dark times ahead

Dark times, eh? The death eaters are abroad, we're already in dark times. But everyone except me is roleplaying everyday life at Hogwarts. What's the matter guys, don't you like dystopia?

[Fleeing Coward]

It seems that the Death Eaters will be recruiting agressively ... dark times ahead

Well, since MOD insists on continuing and Rakkoon just made what I believe to be a classic slip of the tongue, we might as well try to get rid of a real wolf today.

Rakkoon because MOD did not mention anywhere in his post about a recruitment.

Lex-Kat maintains that she copy pasted here PM directly and although I don't fully trust that explanation, I do believe it's a possibility.

[billtodamax]

rakkoon. *batusi*

[Heroic]

Wolfbane I guess

[UncleWolf]

Well, since MOD insists on continuing and Rakkoon just made what I believe to be a classic slip of the tongue, we might as well try to get rid of a real wolf today.

Rakkoon because MOD did not mention anywhere in his post about a recruitment.

Lex-Kat maintains that she copy pasted here PM directly and although I don't fully trust that explanation, I do believe it's a possibility.

That is actually a rather good point.

Rakkoon

[Oddity]

I think he was just RP'ing?

[Fleeing Coward]

It's not rping when he's said the same thing in pms. Let me go find it.

Here it is:

Allow me to wait one more night to say that because apparently the rules are going to change because of the loophole. This could mean that either you or me are going to turn wolfy.

Note that he's saying that after claiming that "he's a power role".

[Murska]

Rakkoon. I think this game should be restarted, myself. We have a mason group, five confirmed villagers and the seer all in one group now.

[Irbis]

Then why you broke it?

[Murska]

Because I could? I only asked three people about their role PMs anyway.

I get bored when I'm not in contact in any games, and I got a fever so I had pretty much nothing whatsoever to do.

[Fawkes]

And when Murska comes calling, you answer.

I didn't know he was trying to break the game, I swear!

[whitehelm]

Rakkoon seems to be a bit suspicious with his mention of wolf recruitment, plus FC and Murska are pointing at him so he doesn't seem to be part of their group, and the Oddity thing looks like it was baseless, so....I'm changing my vote.

[Fawkes]

I'll switch to Rakkoon as well.

[Blue Ghost]

Rakkoon it is. Ugh, what a mess.