Vote Up a Monster #1 (Monster Complete, PEACH)

[Evil DM Mark3]

Fine is fine by me!

[Lyndworm]

I vote Huge.

Zack

[EndlessWrath]

colossal ++ !!! You can do it man

[RTGoodman]

I'll go with Huge. It's big enough to be fearsome, but not so big it's unwieldy or anything.

[Draken]

Huge gets my vote.

[Knaight]

Large. Just a hair bigger than the PCs, solidly built, something that is shapechangery without being monstrous while still big and tough.

[Shadow_Elf]

Fine. It is infinitely more intimidating when it can kill you with its pinky finger and its whole body is the size of your hand...

[vegetalss4]

hmm. change my vote to fine

[Owrtho]

I vote fine.

Owrtho

[Zeta Kai]

Alright, the votes for Size are tallied, & the winner is: Huge!

So, the creature is going to be an Aberration, with the Extraplanar & Shapechanger subtypes. It's Size is going to be Huge. This sounds like it's going to be a very interesting one. So next, I need you guys (& girls) to vote on the creature's Alignment. Votes will be tallied regularly. Please only vote for only 1 alignment, & please don't debate alignments, thank you.

[CrazyMacGuy]

How about say... Neutral Evil?

Yea... thats my vote and i'm sticking to it...

[Knaight]

True Neutral.

[Owrtho]

Alien

and barring that, probly neutral evil.

Owrtho

[Knaight]

Speaking of which it would probably be better to count up the votes on the chaos-law axis, and good-evil axis separately, and find which works best for each one then merge them. After all something with 10 chaotic evil votes, 9 lawful evil votes, 9 lawful neutral votes, 9 lawful good votes, and 0 in everything else should probably be lawful, not chaotic. Similarly something with 10 neutral good votes, 9 chaotic evil votes, 9 neutral evil votes, and 9 lawful evil votes should probably be evil.

[Owrtho]

but what if you get something like 8 lawful good, 9 lawful neutral, 10 neutral evil, and 9 chaotic evil (0 for everything else). Then it would turn out lawful evil which no one voted for.

Owrtho

[Prometheus]

However it is counted, my vote is easy: True neutral!

[Eighth_Seraph]

I dunno if I'm the only one hears this creature roaring "Far Realms!" in a frighteningly thick font, but let's throw something a little different into the mix, shall we? Just imagine a 15-foot tall monstrosity from another dimension...that seeks to defend the purity of the universe and all sentient life within.

I vote for Neutral Good.

[shadowxknight]

I vote Lawful Good

Just for the possible laughs.

[streakster]

Chaotic Neutral! Because bicycle elephant turquoise madly!

[Knaight]

but what if you get something like 8 lawful good, 9 lawful neutral, 10 neutral evil, and 9 chaotic evil (0 for everything else). Then it would turn out lawful evil which no one voted for.

Owrtho

Yeah, its a compromise.

[RTGoodman]

Well, it's a shapechanger, and to me those always seemed rather Chaotic, so I'll with that on the one axis. On the other, I'm not sure. I don't know about a Chaotic Good aberration (and I don't like Good monsters usually because their harder to work in a lot of campaigns), but I'm not sure about the other two (CN or CE) either.

If I have to choose though, I guess my vote is gonna be for... Chaotic Evil.

[Lyndworm]

I'm not sure you should compromise on a vote... That's kind of the point, right?

Anyhoo, I vote Lawful Good.

Zack

[Heliomance]

A huge, shapechanging, extraplanar aberration? Clearly, the only option is Lawful Good, for the lulz.

[Kellus]

I've always been a fan of Lawful Neutral, myself.

[Evil DM Mark3]

Lawful and neural. LN.

[JackMage666]

Neutral Good AND Neutral Evil - It's alignment depends on the shape it's in!

[vegetalss4]

Neutral Good AND Neutral Evil - It's alignment depends on the shape it's in!

that sounds like a good idea. but let us expand it. ALL alingments depending on the shape it is in

[Evil DM Mark3]

that sounds like a good idea. but let us expand it. ALL alingments depending on the shape it is in

You know what? I LOVE THIS IDEA! Kinda like Jekyl/Hyde feeling, shape depends on circumstances and alignment depends on shape.

[Pronounceable]

^^Hey we got a winner! But 9 shapes? Nah, that's too much.

Alternates between LG and NE.

[Evil DM Mark3]

LG and NE? No. We need a proper flip flop, LG and CE or LN and CN or at least LE and CG. Or what about LG, CN and NE if we want 3 forms.