Results 391 to 420 of 462
Thread: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
-
2010-12-28, 05:03 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2006
- Location
- In the shadows
- Gender
-
2010-12-28, 08:31 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
May I just say Lex. Well played. You had me fooled completely while I was alive. Welcome to the afterlife
-
2010-12-29, 03:57 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2010
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Indeed, hats off to you. Not to say that I'm not glad you're dead now
Go villagers!
-
2010-12-29, 03:58 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2010
- Location
- Great Britain
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Come on were....erm...wolf. I think. Let me check my handy-dandy list...
-
2010-12-29, 04:36 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- Minnesota
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
You know, to pass the time of the night, we could have drinks in my tavern and just choose who we're going to lynch in the morning.
Maybe the god/narrator can just ignore the vote of the dead person.
*Opens bar*"see the little angels rise up high, how do they rise up, rise up, how do they rise up high?"
-
2010-12-29, 07:04 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2009
- Location
- This Sceptred Isle
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
*Enters bar*
*Has Drink*
you guysh are the besht!
*collapses*Grlump the Elder, a Lvl. 5 Gnome Barbarian with a penchant for food.
-
2010-12-29, 07:09 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2010
- Location
- England
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Quickly, he's down, get him!
-
2010-12-29, 11:31 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Location
- :noitacoL
- Gender
-
2010-12-29, 11:46 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- Minnesota
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Maybe we should do a blood test to see who the werewolf is, although I think the village already knows who we're going to string up.
"see the little angels rise up high, how do they rise up, rise up, how do they rise up high?"
-
2010-12-30, 05:22 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2010
- Location
- Great Britain
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
No wait! Don't rekill me! I'm the seer!
-
2011-01-01, 06:32 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Originally Posted by Captain's log:
... do we have those papers he attached?"
"The papers had been somewhat scattered by the time we got to them. We believe that for the most part, they were the very papers we have been reading through."
"The poor Captain. I wish something could be done. Some small remembrance for him."
Originally Posted by Note on Captain's log:
Originally Posted by Mysterious note:Summary: Andre Fairchilde (Originally Logarr) was killed. He was a Villager.
Day 24 begins now and ends when I feel like it.Last edited by Thufir; 2013-10-27 at 03:20 PM.
"'But there's still such a lot to be done...'
YES. THERE ALWAYS IS."
-
2011-01-01, 06:33 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- Minnesota
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!
Again I march to my death, to respawn again in another game!"see the little angels rise up high, how do they rise up, rise up, how do they rise up high?"
-
2011-01-01, 06:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2009
- Location
- This Sceptred Isle
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Remaining Players...
GrlumpTheElder
Andre Fairchilde
VA_Beds
MtheMinja
Leta
Duneyrr
Lex-Kat
One Wolf to hunt them all
One Wolf to cheat then
One Wolf to lead them to the Dudnon-Marsters Colony
And in the Madness Eat themGrlump the Elder, a Lvl. 5 Gnome Barbarian with a penchant for food.
-
2011-01-01, 07:18 PM (ISO 8601)MtheminjaGuest in the Playground
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Duneyrr
As the last member of the network (a villager), and this phase being the last of the game (due to being at lynch-or-lose (3 villagers, 1 wolf)), it is safe to say that VA_beds and GrlumpTheElder were judged by the network to be villagers, and Duneyrr to be a wolf.
-
2011-01-03, 12:02 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2010
- Location
- Tacoma, WA
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Wait, hold on a second. Saying something is 'safe to say' is just silly. We obviously didn't win with killing Lex, and the game isn't over, so there is one wolf and if we don't get them tonight, we lose.
Honestly? I haven't been active lately (work has been a time killer) and haven't dedicated as much time to the game as you guys have, but looking at M's last few posts I got a lot of red flags.
He's been pushing for me based on... what? because I voted for VA_beds? I didn't do that. Because Andre thought so and he was the last to die? Fair enough, but he didn't offer any reasoning either. Mtheminja is the wolf. If either of you other two were ever contacted by a Mason or an actual member of the network that says otherwise, go ahead and lynch me, but then the wolf would almost have to be Grlump and I'm almost sure he's village so I know that neither of you have been told anything about M.
EDIT: I should make it clear that I was never contacted by the network and am not claiming to be part of it. I'm pretty much in the dark here, which is why I'm probably the best target.Last edited by Duneyrr; 2011-01-03 at 12:05 PM.
-
2011-01-03, 03:15 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2010
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
duneyerr it is
This message was approved in Triplicate by Bureaucrat #36---please submit Form 16-j-43 before reading
-
2011-01-03, 06:04 PM (ISO 8601)MtheminjaGuest in the Playground
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Leta gave VA_beds and Grlump very good evidence that we were what was left of the network. It was formed by scrying, so since he was proven a villager, I am also verified. It was safe to tell you, the last person who didn't know, because if we're wrong, and you're a villager, it's better for you to know.
In light of that, most of your post is meaningless, especially since everybody but you knew "I know that neither of you have been told anything about M" was precisely incorrect. You'll be happy to know that the network agrees, if you weren't the wolf, aka one of VA_beds or Grlump was, "the wolf would almost have to be Grlump" (in other words, VA_beds is trusted), but we're "almost sure he's village", so you are the top suspect. The network consistently put you higher in the wolf probability list than either of them, so now that it's down to the current 3, it definitely makes sense to go with you.
Supposing you are a villager, care to make an argument against who you think the network has fatally put its trust in?
After all, one wants it to be done neatly, either way...
-
2011-01-03, 07:00 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2010
- Location
- Tacoma, WA
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
I'd say you! But your post is both convincing and well constructed.
In hindsight, my point at you feels more reactionary than anything to me now. I was suspicious of you voting me a few cycles ago for not pointing at Kyrian. I thought it strange that everyone jumped on Kyrian right after we had all jumped on cd4 and you... called me out on it? It just felt weird to me.
I don't have much of an argument, actually. I've gotten no PMs for this game and haven't been all that invested. All I can say is, so far, I'm the only one to have voted for Grlump for a long while and I did it as a random vote just to point off-wagon. All of the now confirmed wolves have been voting for VA_beds and Andre. And Grlump is an experienced player here, so I'm sure he's got some tricks up his sleeve. It's not much of a defense, but it's all I have.
Anyway, it wouldn't mean much switching my vote right now since we're pretty much hosed unless you and VA both switch. Oh, and I'm still not completely convinced about you either. I'll be checking all today and tomorrow though, so if VA switches I will.
-
2011-01-04, 07:53 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
I'm just gonna say that whatever way this pans out it's come right down to the wire! Mr. Thufir. A masterclass. Thank you.
-
2011-01-06, 06:29 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
"And what then?"
"Well, er, that's the last record we have."
"And what did you find when you arrived in the area?"
"Well, not much. The whole settlement was deserted as far as we could tell, and following a brief perusal of the papers we thought it best to simply take them and leave the place. We've also been keeping up some exceedingly careful precautions against the possibility any of us may have been infected by this lycanthropic ailment, though a couple of the natives we passed on the way back here seemed very sure we hadn't."
"What did they say?"
"Said we were safe, we were out of the game, or at the end of the game, or something like that. Said it was all over, and we would know the truth soon enough, from the words of the man who died to the world and of the man who does not exist."
"Strange."
"Indeed. They went on to say the rituals would be performed, the man informed, and the Trickster would only be released if it was allowed to be. Nothing else of note until we arrived back here, at these temporary headquarters, and had just started looking over the papers we took when you arrived, ma'am."
"Then what now? At the last point of which we have record, there were 4 settlers still remaining, who might have been werewolves, and my husband. How long must we wait-"
"Not long."
"Terry!"
Spinning around with this cry, she launched herself into his arms. The soldier, though shocked, pulled off a remarkably neat salute, which the newcomer returned more casually before speaking again.
"Colony has been much depleted, sadly. All that remains of the original settlers I left with your men. Regrettably, the entire military group were killed by the werewolves, other than myself and Captain Sanderson - and what happened to him may be even more tragic."
"Who?"
"What?"
"Oh, er... that's, er, not important, really."
"But, Lieutenant-Colonel Miles, sir, we read an account of your disappearance, and the note you left behind. If I may ask, sir, how did you survive?"
"Hard to say, really. At times it seems as though my life was spared simply to provide a narrative framework to the events which transpired. It was all rather curious. Sadly, it seems as if the rituals the natives perform are by no means superstitions, but rather are essential observances, since without them we were all puppets at the mercy of the Trickster. My role in events was a lighter one perhaps, but still not a pleasant one. I ran from the wolves, and with the wolves, and against the wolves, until it was unclear what was happening and why. And at some point there is simply... a gap in my recollection, after which I found myself knowing what was going on in the colony at all times, but unable to act on that knowledge, or to do anything but watch, wait, and deliver the occasional cryptic message. You say I survived, and it's certainly true that I am alive here, now, but it might be said that I did die, running from the wolves, that night. At the very least, through the whimsy of the Trickster, I may as well have been dead to the world through the events which followed."
"Dead to the world?"
"Of course! The man who died to the world! That must be what those natives meant who spoke to us!"
"Oh, you met my, er... friends, did you? Yes, I saw them from time to time in the course of events, though they avoided me. But they sought us out, once it was all over. Yammered on about how we should've performed the rituals. Anyway, I dealt with that issue, and yes, I think that 'the man who died to the world' is what they've been calling me."
"Then who may be the other to whom they referred? The man who does not exist, I think it was?"
"Oh, er... that's, er, not important, really."
"I suppose not. You're alive and well, that's all that matters, isn't it?"
"Quite. Soldier, would you mind going and helping your men with sorting out the survivors? I'd like some time alone with my wife."
"Of course, sir."
"Children here?"
"Yes. They fell asleep. And I didn't want to wake them until- until I knew... well. Yes. I must admit I'm rather tired myself as well, but I just couldn't rest until I knew what had happened."
"Of course. I quite understand."
"What did happen? From your point of view I mean."
"Well, I'll tell you. I told you there's a gap in my recollections. Well, after that, I remember coming to..."
Some time later, he finished speaking. He turned to see his wife asleep, head on his shoulder.
"Poor thing."
He stroked her hair, kissed her on the forehead, and gazed at her in that way people do when they're in love, and overjoyed to be alive to experience it, but unable to express it too enthusiastically for fear of waiting their beautiful partner (A more common convergence of circumstances than you might expect).
"Father?"
"Oh, there you are, my boys. Be quiet, now, your mother's asleep. Is there a bed around here somewhere?"
"Just a small one."
"Well, that's alright, your mother's not particularly big either."
And so he carried his wife to the bed, tucked her in carefully, then tiptoed back out with his two sons, picked them up one in each arm, and placed them on his knees as he sat down again.
"Now listen up, boys. I've got a positively ripping yarn to tell the two of you..."
Summary: Duneyrr was lynched. He was a Werewolf.
The Villagers wiped out the werewolves and won the game!
Congratulations!Last edited by Thufir; 2013-10-27 at 03:25 PM.
"'But there's still such a lot to be done...'
YES. THERE ALWAYS IS."
-
2011-01-06, 06:41 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Recruitment started here.
Game started here.
Survived (3/54):
{table=head]Name|Role
Castaras/GrlumpTheElder II (AL-replaced Day 9)|Villager
Mtheminja|Villager
VA_beds|Villager[/table]
Died:
{table=head]Name|Role|Died
Internet Flea|Villager|Lynched Day 1
GrlumpTheElder|Villager|Killed Night 1
Grag|Villager|Lynched Day 2
billtodamax|Villager|Killed Night 2
VampireRot|Villager|Lynched Day 3
Leta|Villager|Killed Night 3
bruntonspall|Villager|Lynched Day 4
razovor|Mason|Lynched Day 5
Strategos|Replaced by Internet Flea|Autolynched Day 5
The Cyberwolf|Replaced by billtodamax|Autolynched Day 5
(name here)|Replaced by Leta|Autolynched Day 5
Aemoh|Villager|Killed Night 5
Annon|Werewolf|Lynched Day 6
IXI FatTony IXI|Baner|Killed Night 6
Imperial Psycho|Werewolf|Lynched Day 7
Phase|Villager|Killed Night 7
TheBritish|Villager|Lynched Day 8
lostlittlebear|Replaced by bruntonspall|Autolynched Day 8
Robz_defheadz|Replaced by Wheat|Autolynched Day 8
Valaqil|Replaced by TheBritish|Autolynched Day 8
Ramsus|Fool|Killed Night 8
Matt K|Werewolf|Lynched Day 9
Castaras|Replaced by GrlumpTheElder|Autolynched Day 9
Internet Flea II|Mason|Killed Night 9
Alarra|Werewolf|Lynched Day 10
calar|Mason|Killed Night 10
Project Mayhem|Werewolf|Lynched Day 11
bruntonspall II|Villager|Killed Night 11
Kantur|Villager|Lynched Day 12
Helgraf|Replaced by spacebic|Autolynched Day 12
king.com|Replaced by Qwaz|Autolynched Day 12
Philistine|Villager|Autolynched Day 12
Wheat|Mason|Autolynched Day 12
TheBritish II|Villager|Autolynched Day 12
Julian84|Mason|Killed Night 12
Gray Mage|Werewolf|Lynched Day 13
The Bushranger|Villager|Killed Night 13
Zar Peter|Villager|Lynched Day 14
Odd Fielding|Villager|Autolynched Day 14
billtodamax II|Villager|Autolynched Day 14
Orangeban|Werewolf|Lynched Day 15
spacebic|Villager|Autolynched Day 15
Murska|Villager|Killed Night 15
Eldritch Knight|Werewolf|Lynched Day 16
Tasroth|Seer|Killed Night 16
The Fiery Tower|Werewolf|Lynched Day 17
Horoar|Villager|Killed Night 17
Zanshin|Werewolf|Lynched Day 18
Logarr|Replaced by Andre Fairchilde|Autolynched Day 18
Uber-Gam3r|Mason|Killed Night 18
Tydude|Werewolf|Lynched Day 19
madeyegeorge|Villager|Killed Night 19
cd4|Villager|Lynched Day 20
Qwaz|Mason|Killed Night 20
Kyrian|Villager|Lynched Day 21
Ghanz Nmi|Villager|Killed Night 21
Griever|Werewolf|Lynched Day 22
Leta II|Villager|Killed Night 22
Lex-kat|Devil|Lynched Day 23
Andre Fairchilde|Villager|Killed Night 23
Duneyrr|Werewolf|Lynched Day 24[/table]
Nights 4 and 14 no-one died.
Survey time!
Did you enjoy the game?
Did you like your role?
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
What did you think of the narrations?
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
Any other comments?"'But there's still such a lot to be done...'
YES. THERE ALWAYS IS."
-
2011-01-06, 07:00 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
Absolutely. While I love coming up with complicated rulesets, there is a great charm in Classic's simplicity.
Did you like your role?
Narrating is fun.
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
I really was. It seemed to swing back and forth quite a bit, so I was sure the wolves were going to win, and then I was sure the Villagers were going to win, then the wolves, then the villagers, and then the game ended. But of course it went right down to that last day, if they'd lynched someone else, that plus the kill would have won the game for the wolves instead.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
Probably? Given the number of autolynches, I'm not sure (Though it must be noted that while the autolynches reduced the number of villagers, that also reduced the number of people amongst whom the wolves could potentially hide). At any rate, autolynches always happen so really they should be allowed for, and the game was really close as I said. But arguments can possibly be made that if one team or other had done such-and-such, then blah blah blah...
So, probably.
What did you think of the narrations?
I liked them, naturally, though I was having difficulty coming up with ideas from time to time. Also the style I chose imposed a natural restriction on me: since all the narrations were written as accounts from after the fact, the night kills could not in general be described in detail. No omniscient third person narrator. Partly as a result of this, many such narrations ended up being basically all about the NPCs rather than about the person who just died. I hope people who received such narrations, and people who received exceedingly short narrations when I couldn't think of anything interesting, can forgive me for that. Because I had a lot of fun with those NPCs.
Oh, also, I hope people enjoyed my little nods to the WW community as well.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
Terrible. So many late narrations! Need to be a bit more on the ball to keep up with this stuff. I mean it's not as if they required a great deal of thought to write, now is it?
That said, I did keep track of the game reasonably well, especially given I lost my spreadsheet halfway through...
Any other comments?
A great many, which will be detailed in another post. I'm not sure if it'll be quite a day-by-day breakdown of the game from my point of view, but it could end up as such. I have a lot of thoughts about how this game went, regarding role allocation, rules confusion, and the various stuff the two sides did."'But there's still such a lot to be done...'
YES. THERE ALWAYS IS."
-
2011-01-06, 07:44 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2010
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
I really did. I'm amazed how interesting it was even after I died. I certainly enjoyed my time alive a bit more of course but my death was inevitable.
Did you like your role?
Indeed I did. It probably helped that I found out quickly and decided to announce such in a brash plan that happened to be amazingly interestingly timed.
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Indeed I was. For the longest time I thought we'd nailed it. Only later did I realize there were more wolves than I thought there were.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
I'm still fairly new here so it's hard for me to judge these things but I'd say it seems that was the case.
What did you think of the narrations?
They were amazing.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
Honestly I stopped being an active participant so long ago I have no idea. (I have a poor memory.)
Any other comments?
Well it was fun to be included in the network and help it where I could.
It was also quite fun to have an actual rivalry with another player for a good several turns where we both knew what was going on and our battle was to convince other people with no proof but our words that we were the correct one. I was actually surprised I lived through the following night.
It was a real shame the Baner was randomly distrustful of me (especially since he was specifically the person who invited me to the game...by me I mean a group of people that happened to include me) and I think that's part of why he died so quickly though I can't be sure.
Edit: I think all the dead people talking helped me enjoy things a bit too. I hope it wasn't disruptive for the people who were alive.Last edited by Ramsus; 2011-01-06 at 07:46 AM.
-
2011-01-06, 08:14 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Go Team Village!
Did you enjoy the game?
Yeah!
Did you like your role?
Yeah. AL replaced king.com as a Mason.
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Very.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
Yes. Wasn't sure when we lost the seer but when it came down to the wire like that. Only thing that annoyed me was the AL on a Mason But then I suppose it wouldn't have been so close without that.
What did you think of the narrations?
Amazing. Mine will be nowhere near that quality.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
Uh huh. Only came in half way so can't talk about the first half. Didn't mind the slower pace toward the end because this time of year I think almost everyone has stuff they're doing!
Any other comments?
Lex is the devil!!! I'll get you yet
-
2011-01-06, 09:54 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2006
- Location
- Minnesota
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
It was a good game, and I came in very late so I don't have a very legitimate opinion.
However, in my opinion (and only my opinion - I'm *not* trying to throw any bombs) the auto-lynch replacement totally gave the Villagers the advantage.
It only took a day or so for the Villagers to bring me into their network, and by then "we" (I can't take any credit for the magnificent win) knew who the remaining wolves were.
Note - this does not take away from the victory. It's still really hard to win a WW Classic game.
I wouldn't keep an autolynch replacement for Classic - the auto-lynches are *arguably* a system to keep the game balanced. But I delve into a long conversation about game mechanics that has already been had, repeatedly over the course of at least three years.
Anyway, was happy to take a safe night kill away from the real heroes of the game."see the little angels rise up high, how do they rise up, rise up, how do they rise up high?"
-
2011-01-06, 10:21 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Location
- The Fortress of Cereneld
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
That would be a definite yes.
Did you like your role?
My first time as Seer! I was perhaps a bit slow off the mark, but I enjoyed being right at the heart of the network.
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Oh yes. I didn't realise how close it was going to be until after I was killed. I pretty much read my death scene, posted my encouragement for the surviving villagers, then turned around from the computer and asked Thufir how many wolves were left. It was more than I expected.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
I think so. I don't think the actual auto lynches favoured either side. Sure, there were fewer villagers, but from my point of view, that also meant less suspects to scry. And since the game came right down to the wire, I'd consider that balanced.
What did you think of the narrations?
Very interesting style, though sometimes it made them difficult to read, particularly if I was in a hurry.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
I think I remember some late updates, but my attetion has been diverted over the past couple of weeks, so I can't remember clearly. No real issues to complain abiout though.
Any other comments?
Firstly, scrying 2 masons the first 2 nights gave us a big advantage. And then having the guy I scried night 3 claim Seer/Fool the following day... yeah, I wasn't sure I was the Seer at that point, and I knew that had to be a lie.
Secondly, I was both impressed and slightly exasperated with the other members of the network after my death. Impressed, because they were picking out wolves I hadn't suspected. Exasperated because I gave them a couple of my suspicions before my death. One (VA_beds, who I was scrying the night I died) I was wrong (though another night alive would have netted us another network member, so no bad thing there). The other was Lex. As well as the number of wolves, I asked Thufir about my suspicions. I kept wanting to say "lynch her, dammit, she's the Devil!"What do you mean "Dungeon Master" isn't a proper job?
Thanks to Thufir for the avatar.
D&D Characters Past and Present:
Spoiler
The Honest Man (3.5 LG human fighter), Princess Kailee (4e Good elf cleric), Elric (4e Good human paladin)
Talia Dakashnit (3.5 CE human fighter), Gabriel Stryfe (d20 Modern fast hero), Tacin Willow (3.5 NG human fighter//bard)
GitP Blood Bowl Legacy League - Season 3 recruiting
-
2011-01-06, 10:46 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- Whose eye is that eye?
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
I liked the game, and to be frank, it's been one of the few classics I paid attention to, so I can say that I liked it more than usual. The down-to-the-wire ending is always nice, aswell.
I expected to be killed a bit earlier, I'm pretty impressed with the network picking out many of the wolves so quickly even after the Seer's death. I didn't do much for the team other than act as a public voice, but I guess that's part of my specialty anyway.
I liked the narrations, though I admit I didn't read all of them after my death. However, I did keep an eye on the game. I'd suggest having one less wolf except that'd put them down to thirteen and we all know that'd be completely unfair.
-
2011-01-06, 11:48 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Location
- :noitacoL
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
Did you like your role?
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
What did you think of the narrations?
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
Any other comments?
Also...
But you're assuming that cd4 would randomly point at himself, so the odds for finding a wolf each turn are raised by a percent or two. Plus there's the issue of why a wolf would point at four other wolves and then not try anything crazy, since the only point of doing so would be for overanalyzing people who would clear the others based on that vote, which doesn't work if the others die first. (Plus Alarra pointed at him via PM, but I don't think you were there for that.)
So yeah, that's been bothering me.
-
2011-01-06, 12:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2010
- Location
- Tacoma, WA
- Gender
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
Yes! My first classic ever and it was wonderful!
Did you like your role?
Yes and yes! After Annon died and Alarra was called away I took the lead as the 'vote sending in person' and it was fun. Thanks to Lex for actually finding the power roles!
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Honestly? Yes. I thought the wolves were going to win handily, but then we started dropping like flies.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced? At the beginning, yes. Halfway through, no. At the end, yes.
What did you think of the narrations?
Loved the narrations. I liked the sense of panic and the different personalities.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
54 players, no co-narrator, and (somewhat) consistent results? I don't think anyone can really say otherwise.
Any other comments?
I have all of the wolf PMs saved on my laptop. If you want to see what was going on on the wolf side, I'd be happy to post them or give them to Thufir for his write-up (If Lex and Alarra don't mind!)
-
2011-01-06, 12:19 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2005
- Location
Re: Werewolf Classic XII Part 2
Did you enjoy the game?
Yes, Very Much.
Did you like your role?
Heh, this is one of the two first werewolves games I have played, ever. I was a wolf in both. Furture WW games are going to seem so boring now...
Were you impressed by how close the game was?
Yes. I look back and I wonder "if I had just done X instead of Y, would we have won?" (see below) To me, that means it was a very good game.
Did you think the Villager:Wolf ratio was balanced?
Meh...yes, with caveats. I would have preferred a smaller Wolf:Villager ratio, with no AL replacement. I would rather autolynches just die, rather than become semi-trustowrthy villagers.
What did you think of the narrations?
Loved 'em.
Did you think the narrator otherwise did a good job?
I would be cursing your name the day I died if that one villager hadn't voted twice, and I had died because you were late. As it was, you did an excellent job of spotting a double-voter and I died fairly
Any other comments?
I was thiiiiis close to my plot working. The idea was, we already knew who the baner was. The network had asked the baner to contact them publicly. I already knew I was an up-and-coming wolf-skin rug since I had been scryed, but I thought I could take Ramsus and/or a Mason down with me after the baner died the that night if I lived through the day, but my timing was so very, very close. As in, if I had posted a couple hours later, I might have had that one single vote go for Mayhem instead of me.Last edited by Annon; 2011-01-06 at 12:21 PM.
Avatar done by my own hand.